[BUG] buttons and lists stopped working #56

filipeloose · 2023-05-10T03:45:15Z

No description provided.

batarabagus · 2023-05-10T04:51:15Z

Yes, after the latest update on Android today, list and button messages didn't show up on the receiver.

Kawasan-Opensource · 2023-05-10T05:52:16Z

same issue

makanSukros · 2023-05-10T06:09:54Z

Same with me any Solution ?

No solution for now, but to appear on wa web you can still add the viewOnce parameter

vishwajit76 · 2023-05-10T06:24:55Z

Same Issue

arskyy · 2023-05-10T06:43:31Z

it's a sign that it's time for you to change lib:v hehehe

makanSukros · 2023-05-10T07:16:12Z

it's a sign that it's time for you to change lib:v hehehe

It's not about this lib, but indeed at this time WhatsApp has an update and some are missing, I tried other libs and got the same thing, it's good that we try to solve this problem together

lambangwi · 2023-05-10T07:21:30Z

It's not about this lib, but indeed at this time WhatsApp has an update and some are missing, I tried other libs and got the same thing, it's good that we try to solve this problem together

right bro
the problem is not in the lib... there may be an update on the whatsapp server not on the client

KiZakiXD · 2023-05-10T07:42:53Z

itu tandanya sudah saatnya kalian ganti lib:v hehehe

🐒

KiZakiXD · 2023-05-10T07:45:43Z

Rip Baileys?

hmcorpltd · 2023-05-10T08:10:56Z

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

makanSukros · 2023-05-10T08:12:25Z

2, 2228, 8

Not work on ios

MaznAbdullah · 2023-05-10T08:15:09Z

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

wati working /:

lambangwi · 2023-05-10T08:16:57Z

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

btw this using official API. work mobile and web

KiZakiXD · 2023-05-10T08:43:21Z

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

btw this using official API. work mobile and web

api kok ditanya

arskyy · 2023-05-10T09:14:45Z

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

btw this using official API. work mobile and web

api kok ditanya

kamu hengker yah

Fonnte · 2023-05-10T23:23:51Z

FYI, the maintainer have decided to put button feature as deprecated feature. The deprecation will be done in the future. This means the button will not be fixed anymore. It's time to say goodbye to the button feature from the library.

arskyy · 2023-05-10T23:56:29Z

After 5 votes from Contributors, Mods, and even Pedro himself, I've decided to begin the process of deleting Buttons and Lists. The patch that I released a few days ago was either under wraps or not widely applied for a long time (2 months) and the same day I posted it here it has been patched internally by WhatsApp. This timing is very fishy and to not irritate Meta even more, I drew this line. If you're a business, and you profit a lot from every conversion you make, you can go ahead and use the official Meta API for all I care. I've been working discreetly with other library leaders for about 50 hours total all together reverse engineering to figure this out (whatsmeowlead, whatsappweb4j, baileys, openwa and wppconnect) and after all our efforts nothing has worked out. This is what we really end up with in the end because depending on solution after solution whatever you build on top of it will fail. Like building a hospital on bamboo scaffolding. It takes a heavy heart to say this, I know. I also have a mountain of code to change now (Hypere, StormChat, and countless other partners and clients over the years). Open-wa, Baileys, whatsapp-web.js, and wppconnect will be deprecated keys. The process is slightly different for each library but in the end it will all be the same. - purpshell, maintainer of whatsapp-web.js and Baileys for 3 years now (in case you didn't know)

lambangwi · 2023-05-11T00:57:54Z

RIP #Buttons #List :(

sembilan-d · 2023-05-11T03:22:06Z

2, 2228, 8

Not work on ios
Im worked on Ios and Web using "version": [2, 2228, 8]

In IOS Still working

Auties00 · 2023-05-11T09:28:15Z

So I'm gonna have a look today.
Still even if i fix it, at this point you really shouldn't be relying on buttons.

hosamalzagh · 2023-05-11T13:53:08Z

same issue

codemakesense07 · 2023-05-13T08:54:06Z

Same with me any Solution ?

No solution for now, but to appear on wa web you can still add the viewOnce parameter

yeah, the button can still be seen on your 'whatsapp web' but it's not sent to your mobile device... this issue hasn't been fixed for so long

reski-rukmantiyo · 2023-05-13T16:27:36Z

After 5 votes from Contributors, Mods, and even Pedro himself, I've decided to begin the process of deleting Buttons and Lists. The patch that I released a few days ago was either under wraps or not widely applied for a long time (2 months) and the same day I posted it here it has been patched internally by WhatsApp. This timing is very fishy and to not irritate Meta even more, I drew this line. If you're a business, and you profit a lot from every conversion you make, you can go ahead and use the official Meta API for all I care. I've been working discreetly with other library leaders for about 50 hours total all together reverse engineering to figure this out (whatsmeowlead, whatsappweb4j, baileys, openwa and wppconnect) and after all our efforts nothing has worked out. This is what we really end up with in the end because depending on solution after solution whatever you build on top of it will fail. Like building a hospital on bamboo scaffolding. It takes a heavy heart to say this, I know. I also have a mountain of code to change now (Hypere, StormChat, and countless other partners and clients over the years). Open-wa, Baileys, whatsapp-web.js, and wppconnect will be deprecated keys. The process is slightly different for each library but in the end it will all be the same. - purpshell, maintainer of whatsapp-web.js and Baileys for 3 years now (in case you didn't know)

hi @arskyy and teams, thanks for everything that you guys have done until this far. may i know, other than button and list, what else that dev will deprecate (other than on server side)? just precautions. thanks

Auties00 · 2023-05-13T16:58:18Z

I forgot to reply, but there's a server side filter now. So the issue cannot be solved. Btw only buttons, list and template are getting deprecated

reski-rukmantiyo · 2023-05-13T17:42:35Z

I forgot to be reply, but there's a server side filter now. So the issue cannot be solved. Btw only buttons, list and template are getting deprecated

thanks @Auties00 for clarifications.

brekertabumi · 2023-05-29T09:11:15Z

Same with me any Solution ?

No solution for now, but to appear on wa web you can still add the viewOnce parameter

How do you add the viewOnce parameter, can you give an example?

`const buttons = [
{buttonId: "id1", buttonText: {displayText: 'Info 1!'}},
{buttonId: "id2", buttonText: {displayText: 'Info 2!'}},
{buttonId: "id3", buttonText: {displayText: '💵 Info 3'}}
]

const buttonInfo = {
text: "Info Warung Kopi",
buttons: buttons,
viewOnce:true,
headerType: 1
}
await sock.sendMessage(noWa, buttonInfo, {quoted: messages[0]});`

jefaokpta · 2023-06-02T13:22:16Z

Press 'F'

renatoiub · 2023-12-16T00:39:39Z

I tested the buttons and the list again, they worked again on IOS.

rajatency · 2024-01-07T17:57:28Z

Is the buttons feature available now or not on WhatsApp? Is it available on WhatsApp Business?

Fann-level-MAX · 2024-07-30T18:06:53Z

you guys trying to do something like this?

goziyyy · 2024-08-01T05:36:14Z

you guys trying to do something like this?

how? can u explain me?

wahyuba05 · 2024-08-01T05:46:27Z

you guys trying to do something like this?

but in next version baileys,its not work again.right?

Fann-level-MAX · 2024-08-01T05:51:48Z

you guys trying to do something like this?

but in next version baileys,its not work again.right?

you guys trying to do something like this?

how? can u explain me?

i will give you my code later, I'm busy rn and my code was in my laptop

goziyyy · 2024-08-01T06:19:35Z

y

okay

Fann-level-MAX · 2024-08-01T11:25:43Z

okay

import pkg from "@whiskeysockets/baileys"
const { proto, generateWAMessageFromContent, generateWAMessageContent } = pkg

const generate = async (type, url) => {
    const generated = await generateWAMessageContent({
        [type]: { url }
    }, {
        upload: sock.waUploadToServer
    })
    return generated[`${type}Message`]
}

const msg = generateWAMessageFromContent(m.key.remoteJid, {
    viewOnceMessage: {
        message: {
            messageContextInfo: {
                deviceListMetadata: {},
                deviceListMetadataVersion: 2
            },
            interactiveMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.create({
                body: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Body.create({
                    text: "body text (optional)"
                }),
                footer: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Footer.create({
                    text: "footer text (optional)"
                }),
                header: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Header.create({
                    title: "some title",
                    hasMediaAttachment: true, // false if you don't want to send media with it
                    imageMessage: generate("image", "url/path to image"),
                    //videoMessage: generate("video", "url/path to video"), // if it's an video
                }),
                nativeFlowMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.NativeFlowMessage.create({
                    buttons: [{
                        name: "quick_reply",
                        buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                            display_text: "button 1", // <-- displayed text
                            id: ".menu" // <-- this is the id or you may call it command 🤷‍♂️
                        }) // REMEMBER TO USE "JSON.stringify()" BECAUSE "buttonParamsJson" ONLY ACCEPTING STIRNG JSON, NOT AN OBJECT
                    },{
                        name: "cta_url",
                        buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                            display_text: "subscribe my Youtube!",
                            url: "https://youtube.com/@fannmods",
                            merchant_url: "https://youtube.com"
                        })
                    }]
                })
            })
        }
    }
}, {})

await sock.relayMessage(msg.key.remoteJid, msg.message, {
    messageId: msg.key.id
})

this code should be worked

hacxk · 2024-08-01T12:11:13Z

okay

import pkg from "@whiskeysockets/baileys"
const { proto, generateWAMessageFromContent, generateWAMessageContent } = pkg

const generate = async (type, url) => {
    const generated = await generateWAMessageContent({
        [type]: { url }
    }, {
        upload: sock.waUploadToServer
    })
    return generated[`${type}Message`]
}

const msg = generateWAMessageFromContent(m.key.remoteJid, {
    viewOnceMessage: {
        message: {
            messageContextInfo: {
                deviceListMetadata: {},
                deviceListMetadataVersion: 2
            },
            interactiveMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.create({
                body: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Body.create({
                    text: "body text (optional)"
                }),
                footer: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Footer.create({
                    text: "footer text (optional)"
                }),
                header: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Header.create({
                    title: "some title",
                    hasMediaAttachment: true, // false if you don't want to send media with it
                    imageMessage: generate("image", "url/path to image"),
                    //videoMessage: generate("video", "url/path to video"), // if it's an video
                }),
                nativeFlowMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.NativeFlowMessage.create({
                    buttons: [{
                        name: "quick_reply",
                        buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                            display_text: "button 1", // <-- displayed text
                            id: ".menu" // <-- this is the id or you may call it command 🤷‍♂️
                        }) // REMEMBER TO USE "JSON.stringify()" BECAUSE "buttonParamsJson" ONLY ACCEPTING STIRNG JSON, NOT AN OBJECT
                    },{
                        name: "ctl_url",
                        buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                            display_text: "subscribe my Youtube!",
                            url: "https://youtube.com/@fannmods",
                            merchant_url: "https://youtube.com"
                        })
                    }]
                })
            })
        }
    }
}, {})

await sock.relayMessage(msg.key.remoteJid, msg.message, {
    messageId: msg.key.id
})

this code should be worked

But this will don't show in Web Whatsapp, IOS

Fann-level-MAX · 2024-08-01T12:14:05Z

But this will don't show in Web Whatsapp, IOS

they say old method of sending button message still work on IOS and Web
why didn't u just send 2 button?
my code for android and old method for ios and web

wahyuba05 · 2024-08-01T12:17:20Z

But this will don't show in Web Whatsapp, IOS

they say old method of sending button message still work on IOS and Web why didn't u just send 2 button? my code for android and old method for ios and web

its still work for next update whiskeysocket baileys version?

Fann-level-MAX · 2024-08-01T12:21:21Z

its still work for next update whiskeysocket baileys version?

i have no idea
but probably yeah

goziyyy · 2024-08-01T18:06:31Z

But this will don't show in Web Whatsapp, IOS

they say old method of sending button message still work on IOS and Web why didn't u just send 2 button? my code for android and old method for ios and web

Do u have an example code for the old method one? In my case i Gotta go for all of them to make sure all platform should work (is it possible¿)

Fann-level-MAX · 2024-08-02T02:07:43Z

Do u have an example code for the old method one? In my case i Gotta go for all of them to make sure all platform should work (is it possible¿)

i have tested my code and it worked for web

G4br1e3l · 2024-08-23T00:33:40Z

how to send sections?

okay

import pkg from "@whiskeysockets/baileys"
const { proto, generateWAMessageFromContent, generateWAMessageContent } = pkg

const generate = async (type, url) => {
    const generated = await generateWAMessageContent({
        [type]: { url }
    }, {
        upload: sock.waUploadToServer
    })
    return generated[`${type}Message`]
}

const msg = generateWAMessageFromContent(m.key.remoteJid, {
    viewOnceMessage: {
        message: {
            messageContextInfo: {
                deviceListMetadata: {},
                deviceListMetadataVersion: 2
            },
            interactiveMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.create({
                body: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Body.create({
                    text: "body text (optional)"
                }),
                footer: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Footer.create({
                    text: "footer text (optional)"
                }),
                header: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Header.create({
                    title: "some title",
                    hasMediaAttachment: true, // false if you don't want to send media with it
                    imageMessage: generate("image", "url/path to image"),
                    //videoMessage: generate("video", "url/path to video"), // if it's an video
                }),
                nativeFlowMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.NativeFlowMessage.create({
                    buttons: [{
                        name: "quick_reply",
                        buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                            display_text: "button 1", // <-- displayed text
                            id: ".menu" // <-- this is the id or you may call it command 🤷‍♂️
                        }) // REMEMBER TO USE "JSON.stringify()" BECAUSE "buttonParamsJson" ONLY ACCEPTING STIRNG JSON, NOT AN OBJECT
                    },{
                        name: "cta_url",
                        buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                            display_text: "subscribe my Youtube!",
                            url: "https://youtube.com/@fannmods",
                            merchant_url: "https://youtube.com"
                        })
                    }]
                })
            })
        }
    }
}, {})

await sock.relayMessage(msg.key.remoteJid, msg.message, {
    messageId: msg.key.id
})

this code should be worked

Fann-level-MAX · 2024-08-23T01:05:33Z

how to send sections?

let msg = generateWAMessageFromContent(m.key.remoteJid, {
    viewOnceMessage: {
      message: {
        "messageContextInfo": {
          "deviceListMetadata": {},
          "deviceListMetadataVersion": 2
        },
        interactiveMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.create({
          body: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Body.create({
            text: teks
          }),
          footer: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Footer.create({
            text: cright
          }),
          header: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Header.create({
            title: ``,
            videoMessage: await generate("image", { url: thumbnail }),
            hasMediaAttachment: true
          }),
          nativeFlowMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.NativeFlowMessage.create({
            buttons: [{
            name: "quick_reply",
            buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                display_text: "btn 1,
                id: "id 1
            })
        },{
            name: "quick_reply",
            buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                display_text: "btn 2",
                id: "id 2"
            })
        }]
          })
        })
      }
    }
  }, {
    ephemeraExpiration: 86400,
    quoted: m
  })

  await sock.relayMessage(msg.key.remoteJid, msg.message, {
    messageId: msg.key.id
  })

should be work

yrizzz · 2024-09-04T15:00:38Z

okay

import pkg from "@whiskeysockets/baileys"
const { proto, generateWAMessageFromContent, generateWAMessageContent } = pkg

const generate = async (type, url) => {
    const generated = await generateWAMessageContent({
        [type]: { url }
    }, {
        upload: sock.waUploadToServer
    })
    return generated[`${type}Message`]
}

const msg = generateWAMessageFromContent(m.key.remoteJid, {
    viewOnceMessage: {
        message: {
            messageContextInfo: {
                deviceListMetadata: {},
                deviceListMetadataVersion: 2
            },
            interactiveMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.create({
                body: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Body.create({
                    text: "body text (optional)"
                }),
                footer: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Footer.create({
                    text: "footer text (optional)"
                }),
                header: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.Header.create({
                    title: "some title",
                    hasMediaAttachment: true, // false if you don't want to send media with it
                    imageMessage: generate("image", "url/path to image"),
                    //videoMessage: generate("video", "url/path to video"), // if it's an video
                }),
                nativeFlowMessage: proto.Message.InteractiveMessage.NativeFlowMessage.create({
                    buttons: [{
                        name: "quick_reply",
                        buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                            display_text: "button 1", // <-- displayed text
                            id: ".menu" // <-- this is the id or you may call it command 🤷‍♂️
                        }) // REMEMBER TO USE "JSON.stringify()" BECAUSE "buttonParamsJson" ONLY ACCEPTING STIRNG JSON, NOT AN OBJECT
                    },{
                        name: "cta_url",
                        buttonParamsJson: JSON.stringify({
                            display_text: "subscribe my Youtube!",
                            url: "https://youtube.com/@fannmods",
                            merchant_url: "https://youtube.com"
                        })
                    }]
                })
            })
        }
    }
}, {})

await sock.relayMessage(msg.key.remoteJid, msg.message, {
    messageId: msg.key.id
})

this code should be worked

how to get params inside button [] or where documentation for buttonParamsJson ?

Rmgs06 · 2024-09-28T03:46:22Z

Apakah Anda punya contoh kode untuk metode lama? Dalam kasus saya, saya harus menggunakan semuanya untuk memastikan semua platform berfungsi (apakah mungkin¿)

Saya telah menguji kode saya dan berhasil untuk web

I've tried it but the results are different if I use WhatsApp web or desktop

this is my result

in web
in mobile

I don't know what's wrong.

filipeloose added the bug Something isn't working label May 10, 2023

bhavesh53 mentioned this issue May 10, 2023

Button Message stopped working Auties00/Cobalt#278

Closed

ramacatur mentioned this issue May 11, 2023

button and menu on regular whatsapp not work (again) tulir/whatsmeow#381

Closed

hosamalzagh mentioned this issue May 12, 2023

[BUG] buttons and lists stopped working code-chat-br/whatsapp-api#21

Closed

andresayac mentioned this issue May 12, 2023

[BUG] Button SendMessage #62

Closed

tulir mentioned this issue Jun 4, 2023

ListMessage & ButtonsMessage is not working on android but working on IOS and web tulir/whatsmeow#398

Closed

edgardmessias added the wontfix This will not be worked on label Jun 6, 2023

canove mentioned this issue Jun 15, 2023

[BUG] button not working #145

Closed

SheIITear mentioned this issue Jun 23, 2023

[BUG] LIST #178

Closed

andresayac mentioned this issue Aug 2, 2023

button not show andresayac/bot-wa-baileys#4

Closed

arugaz mentioned this issue Sep 16, 2023

fix: fix baileys arugaz/whatsapp-bot#480

Merged

allburov mentioned this issue Sep 21, 2023

new feature - message with button devlikeapro/waha#210

Closed

Auties00 closed this as not planned Won't fix, can't repro, duplicate, stale Oct 5, 2023

Guru322 mentioned this issue Oct 20, 2023

[BUG] Button Issue in Android and iOS #455

Closed

robvanderleek mentioned this issue Dec 13, 2023

Footer and Buttons are not working robvanderleek/mudslide#65

Closed

[BUG] buttons and lists stopped working #56

[BUG] buttons and lists stopped working #56

Comments

filipeloose commented May 10, 2023 • edited Loading

batarabagus commented May 10, 2023

Kawasan-Opensource commented May 10, 2023

makanSukros commented May 10, 2023

vishwajit76 commented May 10, 2023

arskyy commented May 10, 2023

makanSukros commented May 10, 2023

lambangwi commented May 10, 2023

KiZakiXD commented May 10, 2023

KiZakiXD commented May 10, 2023

hmcorpltd commented May 10, 2023

makanSukros commented May 10, 2023

MaznAbdullah commented May 10, 2023

lambangwi commented May 10, 2023

KiZakiXD commented May 10, 2023

arskyy commented May 10, 2023

Fonnte commented May 10, 2023

arskyy commented May 10, 2023

lambangwi commented May 11, 2023

sembilan-d commented May 11, 2023

Auties00 commented May 11, 2023

hosamalzagh commented May 11, 2023

codemakesense07 commented May 13, 2023

reski-rukmantiyo commented May 13, 2023

Auties00 commented May 13, 2023 • edited Loading

reski-rukmantiyo commented May 13, 2023

brekertabumi commented May 29, 2023 • edited Loading

jefaokpta commented Jun 2, 2023

renatoiub commented Dec 16, 2023

rajatency commented Jan 7, 2024

Fann-level-MAX commented Jul 30, 2024

goziyyy commented Aug 1, 2024

wahyuba05 commented Aug 1, 2024

Fann-level-MAX commented Aug 1, 2024

goziyyy commented Aug 1, 2024

Fann-level-MAX commented Aug 1, 2024 • edited Loading

hacxk commented Aug 1, 2024

Fann-level-MAX commented Aug 1, 2024

wahyuba05 commented Aug 1, 2024

Fann-level-MAX commented Aug 1, 2024

goziyyy commented Aug 1, 2024

Fann-level-MAX commented Aug 2, 2024

G4br1e3l commented Aug 23, 2024

Fann-level-MAX commented Aug 23, 2024

yrizzz commented Sep 4, 2024

Rmgs06 commented Sep 28, 2024

filipeloose commented May 10, 2023 •

edited

Loading

Auties00 commented May 13, 2023 •

edited

Loading

brekertabumi commented May 29, 2023 •

edited

Loading

Fann-level-MAX commented Aug 1, 2024 •

edited

Loading