Some command palette commands do nothing

[Kregap]

Godot version

v4.1.rc2.official [4642448]

System information

Windows 11

Issue description

Selecting some of the commands from command palette do nothing. Seems like commands that should open a popup/window fail, while other commands work. Selecting faulty commands from menu directly work.

cmd-palette.mp4

Steps to reproduce

1. Open commands palette (Ctrl+Shift+P).
2. Select "Editor Settings" from the list.
3. Confirm command selection with either return keyboard key or by clicking on "OK" button.
   Expected behaviour
   Command palette popup hides.
   Editor Settings popup opens.
   Actual behaviour
   Command palette popup hides but Editor Settings popup does not open.

Minimal reproduction project

N/A

[Sauermann]

I was able to bisect this to #76719, which was also ported to 3.x.

[aryyya]

This also happens for me on macOS Ventura and v4.1.stable.official.

Many command palette commands do nothing. Additionally the hotkeys assigned to certain actions also do nothing.

For example both the command palette and hotkey for "toggle distraction free mode" do nothing.

[passivestar]

Same problem.
Godot v4.1.1.stable - macOS 13.5.2

Trying to execute "Project Settings", "Export", "New Scene", etc has no effect

[SirLich]

Just a heads-up that I am actively trying to solve this bug. I think I've got some good guesses, but until I can attach a debugger it will be tricky.

I'm quite suspicious of this snippet:

void EditorCommandPalette::_confirmed() {
	TreeItem *selected_option = search_options->get_selected();
	String command_key = selected_option != nullptr ? selected_option->get_metadata(0) : "";
	if (!command_key.is_empty()) {
		hide();
		execute_command(command_key);
	}
}

[mcdz]

Same issue in v4.2 dev 5

[kleonc]

Same issue in v4.2 dev 5

@mcdz v4.2.dev5 was released 9 days ago, #82203 (fixing this issue) was merged 4 days ago and hence is not included in 4.2.dev5. It will be included in the next version.