-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 8
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
YouTube Screenshot Button clones #53
Comments
Hi @GrippenDynamik, thanks for the report. Did you check the code of these extensions to know they are strict copies of this repo? If so, what is the goal? |
I've checked the manifest.json and README.md files. The goal is SEO spam. I'm not trying to convince you that these clones need to be reported. |
I have just checked the first link and you are 100% right. Code is exactly the same than version 4.0.0 of the repo. If the goal is SEO spam, i am OK to try reporting abuse to Mozilla. Did you already report it? Maybe you have already written a comprehensive message to be sent? Note: I am not the owner of this repo nor the publisher of the extension on AMO, just user and contributor. |
I haven't reported any of the extensions listed in the OP, and I haven't composed a message to report them. What I've done so far is report three unrelated clone extensions used for SEO spamming: Mozilla has deleted the first two. My reports to Mozilla contained only this information:
|
Thank you very much @GrippenDynamik for reporting this. I reported the first addon (and the developer account) using the 'report abuse' feature which you mentioned here originally. Now as you have put up the whole list here, it look more annoying. Let's just report all of these addons and developer accounts, hope Mozilla takes all these down.
@joggee-fr @GrippenDynamik what change do you suggest in the license here? |
Following is the message I am using for reporting these addons: This addon is exact copy of https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/youtube-screenshot-button/ (its open sourced code is stolen as it is and published as new addon here). Hence this addon abuses Content policy - "If the add-on is a fork of another add-on, the name must clearly distinguish it from the original and provide a significant difference in functionality and/or code." |
@gurumukhi, I suggest absolutely no change in license. IMHO, the line in Mozilla addons policy is good enough and I support not too restrictive open-source licenses. @GrippenDynamik, thanks again for finding such unfair copies. How did you find these addons? Is it a purely manual search? I have checked all the provided links, all simple copies of version 4.0.0 and reported them to Mozilla. |
I agree with @joggee-fr, this problem can't be solved with a license change. It should be enough to rely on Mozilla's terms or service, or Google's, if someone decides to put copies of your extensions there. Finding new spam add-ons is mostly a manual process: But when you've found one, you can usually find the copies. For https://discourse.mozilla.org/t/someone-published-a-copy-of-my-add-on-on-amo/123606 the keyword was "exif". For the ones in the OP, the descriptions all contain "Shift+A". |
I just added 6 more addon links I found today. |
Someone uploaded version 4.0.0 of your extension with different names:
If you report the users for abuse, Mozilla will probably remove the clones.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: