can't nest subgraphs in flowchart

[masukomi]

The following is a valid subgraph

 graph TB
   subgraph Foo
     a1-->a2
   end

but this is not

 graph TB
   subgraph Foo
     a1-->a2
     subgraph Bar
       b1-->b2
     end
   end

I can't think of a reason subgraphs should not be nestable, and i can think of reasons I'd want them to be.

[knsv]

I agree that they should be nestable. Adding it to the list. Heavily involed in another project right now so the change will when I manage to find time.

[knsv]

The issue is fixed and will be included in next release.

[ubreddy]

looks like the fix has some bugs.

nested subgraph labels at 3 or levels deep are not working well, or if there are two subgraphs within a subgraph too.

[knsv]

Hmm. I wonder if there was a problem with the check in. This is my test page for nested subgraphs or perhaps this one is to simple.

[ubreddy]

Please notice the labels of subgraphs going haywire.

graph TB; I --> IG((IG))

subgraph publicnet
IG --> ELB
NAT
end
subgraph webnet
ELB --> Web1
ELB --> Web2
Web1 --> elb2
Web2 --> elb2
end
subgraph appnet
subgraph C1
subgraph C1cluster1
elb2 --> C1Prod1Ins1
elb2 --> C1Prod1InsN
end
subgraph C1cluster2
elb2 --> C1Prod2Ins1
elb2 --> C1Prod2InsN
end
subgraph C1cluster3
elb2 --> C1Prod3Ins1
elb2 --> C1Prod3InsN
end
end
subgraph C2
subgraph C2cluster1
elb2 --> C2Prod1Ins1
elb2 --> C2Prod1InsN
end
subgraph C2cluster2
elb2 --> C2Prod2Ins1
elb2 --> C2Prod2InsN
end
subgraph C2cluster3
elb2 --> C2Prod3Ins1
elb2 --> C2Prod3InsN
end
end
end
subgraph dbnet
C1Prod1Ins1 --> RDS1
C1Prod1InsN --> RDS1
C1Prod2Ins1 --> RDS1
C1Prod2InsN --> RDS1
C1Prod3Ins1 --> RDS1
C1Prod3InsN --> RDS1
C2Prod1Ins1 --> RDS2
C2Prod1InsN --> RDS2
C2Prod2Ins1 --> RDS2
C2Prod2InsN --> RDS2
C2Prod3Ins1 --> RDS2
C2Prod3InsN --> RDS2
end

[knsv]

Thanks for your example. I can replicate the issue now.

[knsv]

The issue was a bit harder ti fix then anticipated. The proper way to fix this involves a change in dagre-d3. I have submitted such a pull request and if/when this is included in dagre-d3 I will finish the solution of this issue.

The problem is to identify the area in svg that is a subgraph. The positioning engine dagre-d3 positions thins for a good layout that does not necessarily correspond to the order things are in the graph definition so it is a guessing game to find the right section.

[knsv]

The change in dagre-d3 has been released and the fix of the issue with the crazy labels has been pushed into (dev-0.5.0). In that branch there are also some experimental changes for packaging mermaid and for integration so use with care. Look at test/web_render.html for an example of nested subgraphs.

[knsv]

A fix for this has been released in version 0.5.0

[ubreddy]

@knut
Replaced mermaid.full.js of 0.4 with mermaid.js of version 0.5 and the diagrams dont render? read the docs... It should have worked. 
What am I missing? any guidance?
Regards Uday

 On Sunday, 7 June 2015 9:04 PM, Knut Sveidqvist <[email protected]> wrote:

A fix for this has been released in version 0.5.0—
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

[knsv]

Thanks for pointing this out. You also need to add the code below to your page. I will update the docs.

<script>mermaid.initialize({startOnLoad:true});</script>

Knut Sveidqvist
Sent with Sparrow (http://www.sparrowmailapp.com/?sig)

On Tuesday 9 June 2015 at 06:28, Udaya Reddy wrote:

@knut
Replaced mermaid.full.js of 0.4 with mermaid.js of version 0.5 and the diagrams dont render? read the docs... It should have worked.
What am I missing? any guidance?
Regards Uday

On Sunday, 7 June 2015 9:04 PM, Knut Sveidqvist <[email protected] (mailto:[email protected])> wrote:

A fix for this has been released in version 0.5.0—
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

—
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub (#161 (comment)).