AnnotatedScrollBar slides off screen

[gi-b716]

Which version of the app?

WinUI 3 Gallery

Description

In WinUi3 Gallery's AnnotatedScrollBar demo, when the window is not maximized, dragging the slider outside of the window allows it to continue to move

Screenshots

2024-07-19_23-36-16.mp4

Windows version

Windows 11 23H2 (22631)

Additional context

No response

Tasks

Beta Give feedback

No tasks being tracked yet.

[karkarl]

This looks like an issue with AnnotatedScrollBar. Transferring issue to microsoft-ui-xaml repo.

[karkarl]

It seems to be normal to be able to drag scrollviewer in the same pointer event even when the mouse has left the window boundaries. It seems the issue is with the height of the scrollviewer not adapting to the height of the window, since it's a scrollviewer in scrollviewer scenario in WinUI-Gallery. This is poor design in general cases, but makes sense for the gallery scenario.

The question is if this is an issue with all scrollviewer controls, or if it's by design.

[JohnnyWestlake]

I would say this is expected behaviour personally and present on all scroll controls - i.e, the scrollbar captures the pointer and lets you continue scroll even if not directly touching it, partly to improve usability because of how thin the scrollbar can be.

[ranjeshj]

Yes. This is by design.