-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 508
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
OpenDTU Fusion losing connection to HMS-1600-4T #1921
Comments
I can confirm the bug, with the April update the connection to the HMS inverters is unstable. I have reset my Fusion to the last March version, since then the connections to my 3 HMS inverters (2x HMS 1800, 1x HMS 2000) are stable again. |
Habe den selben Fehler! Bei mir ist jedoch der Balken gelb und nicht rot. |
Ich hatte den mit usb genommen: |
@FrodoVDR You told us you rolled back to more stable version from March. Which one of the March's version is the more stable one. V24.4.12 is from April (and the last one) which is NOT stable... |
@Uendji I was asked which version I had used, I assumed that it was the support case. |
thx a lot... I flashed 24.3.31 a few hours ago with the result, connection came up again without waiting until tomorrow morning. Strange behaviour. I'm very curious as to what the reason is. Again thx and have a nice weekend. |
P.S. I found a filled event log after it came up again:
|
FYI: same problem with 24.3.31. connection just broken... |
I have the same issue, but with 1x HM-1500. downgraded to v24.3.15 last weekend, and has been running stable for 3 days now. |
Have/Had the same problem also with older images. |
Same problem for me with Hoymiles HMT-2250 and OpenDTU Fusion, but already since i updated months ago. |
For me the question is: Is it a problem with the Fusion hardware or is it a problem with openDTU which maybe can be corrected. I can still return the Fusion board but will I find a more reliable system for HMS? Looking for advice... |
Software… |
Yes, software! |
Don’t think it’s the DTU hardware, maybe the frequency of the Inverter is shifting a little bit and the connection of DTU and HMS/T is getting broken. |
DTU mit USB aktuellste Version ich nutze die DTU in Verbindung mit dem ioBroker und dem openDTU-Adapter. |
As I mentioned in my first post, connection is still working while no data is showing in openDTU. I can still send commands like limiting output via MQTT to openDTU and it is still sent to HMS and HMS responds as desired... |
I just upgraded to the v24.4.12 for my HM-1500 and I got the no connection to the inverter problem, like the people before me, so nothing new from there but I noticed that nobody mentioned, that there is a problem with the inverter config, which now has a problem with the serial number
as there is mention in the release notes of a new serial parser function, maybe this could be the culprit I hope this helps and many thanks for your great project! UPDATE: |
After 3,5 days, he stopped also with this version.... |
Same problem here, very unstable with HM300, HMS1600, HMS2000; will try 24.4.24 |
I updated my OpenDTU Fusion yesterday to 24.4.24 but today it stopped working with my HMT-2250. Also tried restart, power off/on, |
Just tried AhoyDTU - so far no problems. However I did not succeed to integrate mqtt in Home Assistant. Maybe because there is already opendtu configured (injust copied the opendtu-settings for mqtt in Ahoydtu). |
I now flashed a very old firmware from September 2023 on my OpenDTU-Fusion-Board and did a software reset to default settings - now Wifi will not connect with the standard-wifi-password "openDTU42". Any idea? |
So I got it back running after fiddling with a lot of settings and changing the frequency to 868 MHz |
I do have the same problem since updating to 24.4.24. I updated from 24.1.xx. Before it worked much more stable. Now connection is unstable. When changing the transmission power to another value (higher or lower doesn't matter), I works one time. I use a HMS-2000 |
I've downgraded to the first versiosn from Feburary that knows the HMS2000, reduced polling time from every 10sec and reduced update frequency of power adjustments to every 10 sec, too.
That made it stable again.
I have 1x HM-300, 2x HMS-1600 (new version) and 1x HMS-2000 (new version)
I just won't do any updates from now :-)
|
HMS-2000 is supported since the beginning of last year (2023).
What was your previous polling time and update frequency? If you are updating too often you are filling up the command queue with update requests and no polling commands will be executed anymore. And if you are publishing too often, there is no time to execute the time critical polling commands anymore. |
Where do I find these values? |
The limit update interval depends on your own algorithm and how you are setting the current limit (web api, mqtt, etc). if you send this value too often... see above... |
what is "best practice" on a normal install? |
Same with me. I change power settings now every morning. After that it works for around 24 hours. Strange. Also i reset the polling Intervall back from 10 to 5 seconds. I really hope someone will look at this bug, the downgrades did not work for me. |
A user in the discussion forum just said that i should use an other power supply (stronger one). I used it and since that the DTU got every update since 2 hours. btw v24.1.26 is installed |
Did not work for me. But 2 hours is not enough to test. For me the dtu always works for 24 hours. After that i have to change transmitting power, than it works again for 24 hours. |
Just installed v24.5.6 - sadly the problem persists. After reboot no data could be fetched. The trick with changing transmission power still works. |
@tbnobody |
Since yesterday the trick of changing transmission power no longer works for me since yesterday. Started several downgrades, got it to work for yesterday by vhaning frequency to 93,5. Today nothings works. Seems openDTU Fusion is somehow wrecked. Does the normal openDTU also have these problems? I tried AhoyDTU (different hardware) but when i copied the matt-settings that used to work with OpenDTUFusion, Home Assistant would not get any data. |
@justwords28 regarding the hardware: thx & greetings |
Ich habe es wie folgt bei mir feststellen können: Kann das jemand von euch bestätigen bzw. testen? |
ich habe heute das update auf die 24.5.6 gemacht und direkt danach ging keinerlei Kommunikation mit meinem HMS-1600 mehr. mit dem HMS-400 dagegen lief es weiterhin einwandfrei. sehr seltsam. danach diverse downgrades versucht, bis runter zur 31.3.24 aber die Kommunikation kam nur sporadisch zurück. Selbst ein powercycle des HMS-1600 half nichts. erst ein power-cycle der openDTU half. (soft-reset half nichts) |
I think we are facing the same issue. We installed our system around mid of april. OpenDTU connected just fine from the beginning and had no connection problems for about 2 weeks. At a cloudy day we noticed, that no data was delivered anymore and saw the time counter running up with no response from hms. The terminal output looked just the same as in screenshot from @Uendji above. Then i tried fix it by moving the dtu next to the hms, changing settings like send power, restarting openDTU, updating firmware etc. Today, about 2 weeks later, we had the 2nd connection lost this morning. Sadly i didn't save the message history. But i remember it stated the following: hms started around 5:54 am and had some under-voltage and under-frequency logs until the connection was lost at about 6:08 am
P.S.: Just saw, that open-dtu still received the hms logs from this morning after reconfiguration: P.P.S.: With a closer look, i can see by received values in Home-Asistant , that both times, the disconnect did not appear in the morning, but during the day. First time at about 11:30, other day at 13:45. So my observation is, that is has nothing to do with low voltage in the very early morning or such. |
Experiencing the same issue using 24.6.29 with hms1600-4T |
What happened?
Almost every morning after a few hours working fine, connection to HMS is lost. Sometimes it works for two or three days, then connection lost until next morning. But HMS is still working and I am still able to send MQTT-commands such as reducing power or restart converter. But no more info from OpenDTU till next morning. Restarting DTU or powercycle DTU also no effect...
To Reproduce Bug
read above
Expected Behavior
NOT losing connection
Install Method
Pre-Compiled binary from GitHub
What git-hash/version of OpenDTU?
v24.4.12
Relevant log/trace output
Anything else?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: