-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Support aliasing in PARTITION BY #4813
Comments
big-andy-coates
added a commit
to big-andy-coates/ksql
that referenced
this issue
Mar 18, 2020
Fixes: confluentinc#4749 ##### Background This change fixes an issue with our repartition semantics. Old style query semantics for partition by are broken: S1: ROWKEY => B, C (Meaning S1 has a schema with ROWKEY as the key column, and B and C as value columns - types aren't important). ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY B; ``` S2: ROWKEY => B, C As you can see the schema of S2 is still the same. However, the old data in the key has been lost as its been overridden with the data from B, and the key now duplicates the data stored in B. This loss of data on a `SELECT * .. PARTITION BY` needed fixing. Secondly, with new primitive key [work to remove the restriction on key column naming](confluentinc#3536), the same query semantics do not work. e.g. S1: A => B, C ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY B; ``` S2: B => B, C This fails as the `B` value column clashes with the `B` key column! ##### The fix This commit fixes the PARTITION BY semantics so that any PARTITION BY on a specific column sees the old key column being moved to the value and the new key column being moved from the value to the key. For example, S1: A => B, C ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY B; ``` Results in the schema: S2: B => C, A. If a PARTITION BY is an expression other than a column reference, then ksql will synthesis a new column name. For example, S1: A => B, C ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY CAST(B AS INT); ``` Results in the schema: S2: KSQL_COL_0 => B, C, A. [This github issue](confluentinc#4813) will add the ability to use aliases in PARTITION BY expressions, allowing a custom name to be assigned.
2 tasks
once this work is done we can move the call to |
big-andy-coates
added a commit
that referenced
this issue
Mar 20, 2020
* fix: fix repartition semantics Fixes: #4749 ##### Background This change fixes an issue with our repartition semantics. Old style query semantics for partition by are broken: S1: ROWKEY => B, C (Meaning S1 has a schema with ROWKEY as the key column, and B and C as value columns - types aren't important). ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY B; ``` S2: ROWKEY => B, C As you can see the schema of S2 is still the same. However, the old data in the key has been lost as its been overridden with the data from B, and the key now duplicates the data stored in B. This loss of data on a `SELECT * .. PARTITION BY` needed fixing. Secondly, with new primitive key [work to remove the restriction on key column naming](#3536), the same query semantics do not work. e.g. S1: A => B, C ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY B; ``` S2: B => B, C This fails as the `B` value column clashes with the `B` key column! ##### The fix This commit fixes the PARTITION BY semantics so that any PARTITION BY on a specific column sees the old key column being moved to the value and the new key column being moved from the value to the key. For example, S1: A => B, C ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY B; ``` Results in the schema: S2: B => C, A. If a PARTITION BY is an expression other than a column reference, then ksql will synthesis a new column name. For example, S1: A => B, C ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY CAST(B AS INT); ``` Results in the schema: S2: KSQL_COL_0 => B, C, A. [This github issue](#4813) will add the ability to use aliases in PARTITION BY expressions, allowing a custom name to be assigned. Co-authored-by: Andy Coates <[email protected]>
big-andy-coates
added a commit
that referenced
this issue
Mar 23, 2020
* fix: fix repartition semantics Fixes: #4749 ##### Background This change fixes an issue with our repartition semantics. Old style query semantics for partition by are broken: S1: ROWKEY => B, C (Meaning S1 has a schema with ROWKEY as the key column, and B and C as value columns - types aren't important). ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY B; ``` S2: ROWKEY => B, C As you can see the schema of S2 is still the same. However, the old data in the key has been lost as its been overridden with the data from B, and the key now duplicates the data stored in B. This loss of data on a `SELECT * .. PARTITION BY` needed fixing. Secondly, with new primitive key [work to remove the restriction on key column naming](#3536), the same query semantics do not work. e.g. S1: A => B, C ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY B; ``` S2: B => B, C This fails as the `B` value column clashes with the `B` key column! ##### The fix This commit fixes the PARTITION BY semantics so that any PARTITION BY on a specific column sees the old key column being moved to the value and the new key column being moved from the value to the key. For example, S1: A => B, C ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY B; ``` Results in the schema: S2: B => C, A. If a PARTITION BY is an expression other than a column reference, then ksql will synthesis a new column name. For example, S1: A => B, C ```sql CREATE STREAM S2 AS SELECT * FROM S1 PARTITION BY CAST(B AS INT); ``` Results in the schema: S2: KSQL_COL_0 => B, C, A. [This github issue](#4813) will add the ability to use aliases in PARTITION BY expressions, allowing a custom name to be assigned. * fix: do not filter out rows where PARTITION BY resolves to null Fixes: #4747 This commit removes the filter that was excluding any rows where the `PARTITION BY` clause resolved to a `null` value, i.e. either because the result was `null` or because an error occurred evaluating the expression. This change will only affect new queries started. Pre-existing queries will continue to run as before. * docs: call out limitation of partiiton by NULL
This was referenced Mar 24, 2020
2 tasks
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
With the work to allow key columns to have any name and fixing PARTITION BY semantics ksql can now take a schema such as
A => B, C
and PARTITION BYB
to getB => C, A
, which is great. However, if we partition byMY_UDF(B AS INT)
then we currently synthesize a new key column name, so the schema becomesKSQL_COL_0 => B, C, A
.We should allow uses to alias the partition by expression to allow them to provide a name, e.g.:
... PARTITION BY B AS D
results in schemaD => C, A
, i.e.B
is still dropped from the value.... PARTITION BY UDF(B, D) AS K
results in schemaK => B, C, A
.The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: