EIPIP Meeting 41 Agenda

[poojaranjan]

Date and Time

Wednesday, Sep 22, 2021, at 15:00 UTC

Location

Zoom: TBA in the Discord #eip-editing channel

YouTube Live Stream/Recording: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4cwHXAawZxpLrRIkDlBjDUUrGgF91pQw

Agenda

1. Process for Networking EIPs

2. Progress update on moving to "Stagnant" by bot. Ref: eip-bot

3. Decision on closing Issues

4. EIPs Insight - Monthly EIPs status reporting

5. Review action items from the previous meetings

(Anything else, please add a comment)

[alita-moore]

I should be able to make but just in case I can't here's the updates about the stagnant bot (and all bots):

Since last time, the following work as been completed:

• [bug] eth-bot response to the pull request created by bot for status change ethereum/EIP-Bot#15
• [Improvement suggestion] PR title created by bot  ethereum/EIP-Bot#14
• [bug, feature] Stagnant bot shouldn't mention EIP Editors. ethereum/EIP-Bot#13
• [bug] Stagnant bot isn't listing authors in original message. ethereum/EIP-Bot#12
• [EIP Bot] Support multiple files at once alita-moore/PM#4
• https://github.com/ethereum-cat-herders/EIPIP/issues/73#issuecomment-879999394 (with consensus, it would be good to close this because the bot is currently live, some work still needs to be done, but the initial implementation is complete)
• [bug] editors weren't mentioned ethereum/EIP-Bot#6
• [bug] PR 3767 merged without approval ethereum/EIP-Bot#11

Priorities Moving Forward

As per the meeting discussion this issue is top priority

• [feature] bot should not open a PR for EIPs with active pull requests against them (non-bot generated) ethereum/EIP-Bot#17

I intend on addressing the eip-bot bugs first before exploring more feature (and also being available for fixes to the stagnant bot when bugs arise). In particular these issues:

• [bug] Bot not auto merging after author approves ethereum/EIP-Bot#8
• [bug] Should not list emails upon pinging ethereum/EIP-Bot#9
• [bug] investigate why first time bot is marking greg as a first timer alita-moore/PM#9

The outstanding feature requests are..

• [feature] Mention different editors for different types of EIPs ethereum/EIP-Bot#7 (this one is low hanging fruit so I'll do it first)
• [feature] add asset management to bot alita-moore/PM#5
• [feature] Bot should allow non-EIP changes ethereum/EIP-Bot#5
• [feature] Author should be able to move an EIP to Withdrawn. ethereum/EIP-Bot#16

NOTE

• Please leave feature and bug requests as an issue in the ethereum/eip-bot repo because otherwise it's challenging to track what needs to be done.
• If you would like to me to update my prioritization please let me know

[lightclient]

Time permitting, would like to briefly discuss the current thinking around an Open Rollup specification.

[poojaranjan]

Closing in favor of #87