Allow nodes that fail to include removed in event logs.

[handanyolak]

Ethers Version

6.3.0

Search Terms

invalid value for value.removed

Describe the Problem

I upgrade ethers today from v5 to v6.
everything works correctly but the events of contracts not working correctly for me.

e.g. I'm trying to get Approval events of a standard ERC20 token.

but when the Approval event is fired, I see this message on my console.

btw, I use ethers with typechain (I don't know if it is important)
@typechain/ethers-v6: 0.3.0
typechain: 8.1.1

Application: Vue 3
Chain: Ganache
Wallet: Metamask

Code Snippet

erc20.on(
  erc20.filters.Approval,
  (owner, spender, value) => {
    console.log('owner', owner)
  }
)

Contract ABI

No response

Errors

@TODO Error: invalid value for value.removed (invalid boolean; undefined (argument="value", value=null, code=INVALID_ARGUMENT, version=6.3.0)) (value={ "address": "0x3ff0c88213b1c69121b614dafe8f6eff336ebd19", "blockHash": "0x8596a66a031520f66f96ed6cdd8f4da04532e7b1fba75b46f2c35e26c5d8fdd7", "blockNumber": "0x7c", "data": "0x0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000", "logIndex": "0x0", "topics": [ "0x8c5be1e5ebec7d5bd14f71427d1e84f3dd0314c0f7b2291e5b200ac8c7c3b925", "0x000000000000000000000000e627ba1d98037b2aeb207761a4d57dcd43d0cf1e", "0x000000000000000000000000dfab784d4b6da084dafbd032c7c8b3c03347aff1" ], "transactionHash": "0x0ce35a745d0e73457a37e3e948607f78ad409e4d088be48b6a40185ddf8bf750", "transactionIndex": "0x0", "type": "mined" }, code=BAD_DATA, version=6.3.0)
    at makeError (errors.ts:663:21)
    at assert (errors.ts:680:25)
    at format.ts:58:17
    at formatLog (format.ts:107:12)
    at BrowserProvider._wrapLog (abstract-provider.ts:487:24)
    at FilterIdEventSubscriber._emitResults (subscriber-filterid.ts:160:49)
    at FilterIdEventSubscriber.poll_fn3 (subscriber-filterid.ts:96:24)

Environment

Ganache

Environment (Other)

No response

[ricmoo]

I'll look at this first thing tomorrow, because that definitely shouldn't happen.

[emretepedev]

Same issue here.

invalid value for value.removed

I temporarily removed the removed property from the object in the source code to continue my project development.

Not a good solution but everything works well.

[ricmoo]

Fixed in v6.4.0.

Thanks! :)

[sahfd4eiugf]

I'm still having a similar issue with v6.9.2.
Tried with and without filters, still no way to get any logs.
This is from hardhat console on localhost:

eth_getLogs

Errors encountered in param 0: Invalid value "0x01210bdc" supplied to : RpcFilterRequest/fromBlock: (QUANTITY | "earliest" | "latest" | "pending" | "safe" | "finalized") | undefined/0: QUANTITY, Invalid value "0x01210bdc" supplied to : RpcFilterRequest/fromBlock: (QUANTITY | "earliest" | "latest" | "pending" | "safe" | "finalized") | undefined/1: "earliest" | "latest" | "pending" | "safe" | "finalized"