Render building=static_caravan as residential buildings

[achadwick]

Could building=static_caravan (wiki, example) be rendered using the same residential style as for houses please? The outline is too heavy right now: compare the example to the surrounding houses.

Seems to be most common expression for the concept in Taginfo.

[matthijsmelissen]

We will solve this issue by rendering the houses more heavy, rather than by rendering the caravans lighter. There is already a push request in place to accomplish that, see #490. I don't think a further fix is needed, so I will close this issue.

[dieterdreist]

2014-05-19 1:41 GMT+02:00 math1985 [email protected]:

We will solve this issue by rendering the houses more heavy, rather than
by rendering the caravans lighter.

IMHO a caravan (also "static" / "fix" ones) do qualify perfectly as light
buildings, so making them lighter seems a good option anyway, also with
general residential buildings emphasized.

[achadwick]

As I understand it from a fairly cursory read, #490 makes the relatively rare building=mobile_home (and maybe building:type=mobile_home too) (4024 instances in total, 825 of which are building=mobile_home) a light building, but containst nothing about the much more common (13397 instances, 3x as many) building=static_caravan tag.

These objects are almost exactly the same thing: they are both forms of light prefabricated dwelling. They should be rendered as either lighter than houses, or at the same weight. They are both currently rendered heavier, and when #490 makes the live site, static_caravan will render at the same weight as a brick-and-mortar house but mobile_home will be lighter.

(As it happens, I interpret "mobile_home"s as meaning "big prefabricated dwellings" and "static_caravan"s as meaning smaller prefab dwellings. The OSM wiki and Wikipedia equate the two, so don't trust my interpretation.)

Please re-open this issue: its main concern has not been addressed.

[matthijsmelissen]

I agree, but please note that most building=static_caravan tags are added by the Dutch BAG import.

I re-open the issue.

[achadwick]

Thanks, and thanks also for working on this.

An overpass query (Wizard “"building:type"=mobile_home and source!=WakeGIS”) reveals that all 3199 "building:type=mobile_home"s are the result of the Wake County GIS (North Carolina, USA) import ☺

[matthijsmelissen]

This has been solved in the meanwhile.