-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2.1k
Allow admins to proactively block rooms #11228
Conversation
548eb5f
to
98dce15
Compare
98dce15
to
3bd4984
Compare
Co-authored-by: Dirk Klimpel <[email protected]>
|
||
# This will work even if the room is already blocked, but that is | ||
# desirable in case the first attempt at blocking the room failed below. | ||
# Action the block first (even if the room doesn't exist yet) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
I almost feel as though we want to pull the room blocking bit out of this function and put the logic into _delete_room
. Then only call shutdown_room
and purge_room
if the room is known. That may make the control flow slightly simpler?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
I was a little reluctant here.
I didn't like the idea that the block could succeed only for the shutdown/purge to fail; I'd rather the whole thing succeed or fail atomically. But that's the situation today and wouldn't be introduced by your change. It would maybe mean checking twice that a room exists, which is a bit sad.
I'm kinda of the view that this is best left alone for now---I feel like blocking might merit being its own separate API call. How does that sit with you?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
I am not sure if a simple block needs a new API. But I suspect it.
I am try to bring the delete API to a background task. #11223
I do not know how to handle a simple block in V2 API. A block request bring to background is not a good solution. If I am a user, I would except to get a response immediately.
An alternative for V2 API is to response for a simple block other than a shutdown or purge. But I do not like an API with two different return types.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
It is related to #5575.
Maybe should the API return if the blocked room is known or unknown for the Homeserver.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
I'm kinda of the view that this is best left alone for now---I feel like blocking might merit being its own separate API call. How does that sit with you?
I think shutting down a room should still block it, but separating a single block out into its own API call does sound like it'd be cleaner and better long-term. Leaving this alone for now with the hope of refactoring it all later sounds fine. Can you write up a ticket for the idea?
@dklimpel placing the shutdown room handling into a background process does sound like something that should happen regardless. I'm not sure how it relates to moving blocking of a room into a separate API however. Room blocking should be a relatively quick process.
Co-authored-by: Andrew Morgan <[email protected]>
Co-authored-by: Andrew Morgan <[email protected]>
It also fixes #2392 ? |
I think so. Have linked it to this PR, which will close it when this merges. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
lgtm otherwise. I left https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/pull/11228/files#r741843724 open for discussion, even though I don't expect a change off the back of it.
Co-authored-by: Andrew Morgan <[email protected]>
Synapse 1.48.0 (2021-11-30) =========================== This release removes support for the long-deprecated `trust_identity_server_for_password_resets` configuration flag. This release also fixes some performance issues with some background database updates introduced in Synapse 1.47.0. No significant changes since 1.48.0rc1. Synapse 1.48.0rc1 (2021-11-25) ============================== Features -------- - Experimental support for the thread relation defined in [MSC3440](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#3440). ([\#11161](matrix-org/synapse#11161)) - Support filtering by relation senders & types per [MSC3440](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#3440). ([\#11236](matrix-org/synapse#11236)) - Add support for the `/_matrix/client/v3` and `/_matrix/media/v3` APIs from Matrix v1.1. ([\#11318](matrix-org/synapse#11318), [\#11371](matrix-org/synapse#11371)) - Support the stable version of [MSC2778](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#2778): the `m.login.application_service` login type. Contributed by @tulir. ([\#11335](matrix-org/synapse#11335)) - Add a new version of delete room admin API `DELETE /_synapse/admin/v2/rooms/<room_id>` to run it in the background. Contributed by @dklimpel. ([\#11223](matrix-org/synapse#11223)) - Allow the admin [Delete Room API](https://matrix-org.github.io/synapse/latest/admin_api/rooms.html#delete-room-api) to block a room without the need to join it. ([\#11228](matrix-org/synapse#11228)) - Add an admin API to un-shadow-ban a user. ([\#11347](matrix-org/synapse#11347)) - Add an admin API to run background database schema updates. ([\#11352](matrix-org/synapse#11352)) - Add an admin API for blocking a room. ([\#11324](matrix-org/synapse#11324)) - Update the JWT login type to support custom a `sub` claim. ([\#11361](matrix-org/synapse#11361)) - Store and allow querying of arbitrary event relations. ([\#11391](matrix-org/synapse#11391)) Bugfixes -------- - Fix a long-standing bug wherein display names or avatar URLs containing null bytes cause an internal server error when stored in the DB. ([\#11230](matrix-org/synapse#11230)) - Prevent [MSC2716](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#2716) historical state events from being pushed to an application service via `/transactions`. ([\#11265](matrix-org/synapse#11265)) - Fix a long-standing bug where uploading extremely thin images (e.g. 1000x1) would fail. Contributed by @Neeeflix. ([\#11288](matrix-org/synapse#11288)) - Fix a bug, introduced in Synapse 1.46.0, which caused the `check_3pid_auth` and `on_logged_out` callbacks in legacy password authentication provider modules to not be registered. Modules using the generic module interface were not affected. ([\#11340](matrix-org/synapse#11340)) - Fix a bug introduced in 1.41.0 where space hierarchy responses would be incorrectly reused if multiple users were to make the same request at the same time. ([\#11355](matrix-org/synapse#11355)) - Fix a bug introduced in 1.45.0 where the `read_templates` method of the module API would error. ([\#11377](matrix-org/synapse#11377)) - Fix an issue introduced in 1.47.0 which prevented servers re-joining rooms they had previously left, if their signing keys were replaced. ([\#11379](matrix-org/synapse#11379)) - Fix a bug introduced in 1.13.0 where creating and publishing a room could cause errors if `room_list_publication_rules` is configured. ([\#11392](matrix-org/synapse#11392)) - Improve performance of various background database updates. ([\#11421](matrix-org/synapse#11421), [\#11422](matrix-org/synapse#11422)) Improved Documentation ---------------------- - Suggest users of the Debian packages add configuration to `/etc/matrix-synapse/conf.d/` to prevent, upon upgrade, being asked to choose between their configuration and the maintainer's. ([\#11281](matrix-org/synapse#11281)) - Fix typos in the documentation for the `username_available` admin API. Contributed by Stanislav Motylkov. ([\#11286](matrix-org/synapse#11286)) - Add Single Sign-On, SAML and CAS pages to the documentation. ([\#11298](matrix-org/synapse#11298)) - Change the word 'Home server' as one word 'homeserver' in documentation. ([\#11320](matrix-org/synapse#11320)) - Fix missing quotes for wildcard domains in `federation_certificate_verification_whitelist`. ([\#11381](matrix-org/synapse#11381)) Deprecations and Removals ------------------------- - Remove deprecated `trust_identity_server_for_password_resets` configuration flag. ([\#11333](matrix-org/synapse#11333), [\#11395](matrix-org/synapse#11395)) Internal Changes ---------------- - Add type annotations to `synapse.metrics`. ([\#10847](matrix-org/synapse#10847)) - Split out federated PDU retrieval function into a non-cached version. ([\#11242](matrix-org/synapse#11242)) - Clean up code relating to to-device messages and sending ephemeral events to application services. ([\#11247](matrix-org/synapse#11247)) - Fix a small typo in the error response when a relation type other than 'm.annotation' is passed to `GET /rooms/{room_id}/aggregations/{event_id}`. ([\#11278](matrix-org/synapse#11278)) - Drop unused database tables `room_stats_historical` and `user_stats_historical`. ([\#11280](matrix-org/synapse#11280)) - Require all files in synapse/ and tests/ to pass mypy unless specifically excluded. ([\#11282](matrix-org/synapse#11282), [\#11285](matrix-org/synapse#11285), [\#11359](matrix-org/synapse#11359)) - Add missing type hints to `synapse.app`. ([\#11287](matrix-org/synapse#11287)) - Remove unused parameters on `FederationEventHandler._check_event_auth`. ([\#11292](matrix-org/synapse#11292)) - Add type hints to `synapse._scripts`. ([\#11297](matrix-org/synapse#11297)) - Fix an issue which prevented the `remove_deleted_devices_from_device_inbox` background database schema update from running when updating from a recent Synapse version. ([\#11303](matrix-org/synapse#11303)) - Add type hints to storage classes. ([\#11307](matrix-org/synapse#11307), [\#11310](matrix-org/synapse#11310), [\#11311](matrix-org/synapse#11311), [\#11312](matrix-org/synapse#11312), [\#11313](matrix-org/synapse#11313), [\#11314](matrix-org/synapse#11314), [\#11316](matrix-org/synapse#11316), [\#11322](matrix-org/synapse#11322), [\#11332](matrix-org/synapse#11332), [\#11339](matrix-org/synapse#11339), [\#11342](matrix-org/synapse#11342)) - Add type hints to `synapse.util`. ([\#11321](matrix-org/synapse#11321), [\#11328](matrix-org/synapse#11328)) - Improve type annotations in Synapse's test suite. ([\#11323](matrix-org/synapse#11323), [\#11330](matrix-org/synapse#11330)) - Test that room alias deletion works as intended. ([\#11327](matrix-org/synapse#11327)) - Add type annotations for some methods and properties in the module API. ([\#11341](matrix-org/synapse#11341)) - Fix running `scripts-dev/complement.sh`, which was broken in v1.47.0rc1. ([\#11368](matrix-org/synapse#11368)) - Rename internal functions for token generation to better reflect what they do. ([\#11369](matrix-org/synapse#11369), [\#11370](matrix-org/synapse#11370)) - Add type hints to configuration classes. ([\#11377](matrix-org/synapse#11377)) - Publish a `develop` image to Docker Hub. ([\#11380](matrix-org/synapse#11380)) - Keep fallback key marked as used if it's re-uploaded. ([\#11382](matrix-org/synapse#11382)) - Use `auto_attribs` on the `attrs` class `RefreshTokenLookupResult`. ([\#11386](matrix-org/synapse#11386)) - Rename unstable `access_token_lifetime` configuration option to `refreshable_access_token_lifetime` to make it clear it only concerns refreshable access tokens. ([\#11388](matrix-org/synapse#11388)) - Do not run the broken MSC2716 tests when running `scripts-dev/complement.sh`. ([\#11389](matrix-org/synapse#11389)) - Remove dead code from supporting ACME. ([\#11393](matrix-org/synapse#11393)) - Refactor including the bundled relations when serializing an event. ([\#11408](matrix-org/synapse#11408))
Synapse 1.48.0 (2021-11-30) =========================== This release removes support for the long-deprecated `trust_identity_server_for_password_resets` configuration flag. This release also fixes some performance issues with some background database updates introduced in Synapse 1.47.0. Features -------- - Experimental support for the thread relation defined in [MSC3440](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#3440). ([\#11161](matrix-org/synapse#11161)) - Support filtering by relation senders & types per [MSC3440](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#3440). ([\#11236](matrix-org/synapse#11236)) - Add support for the `/_matrix/client/v3` and `/_matrix/media/v3` APIs from Matrix v1.1. ([\#11318](matrix-org/synapse#11318), [\#11371](matrix-org/synapse#11371)) - Support the stable version of [MSC2778](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#2778): the `m.login.application_service` login type. Contributed by @tulir. ([\#11335](matrix-org/synapse#11335)) - Add a new version of delete room admin API `DELETE /_synapse/admin/v2/rooms/<room_id>` to run it in the background. Contributed by @dklimpel. ([\#11223](matrix-org/synapse#11223)) - Allow the admin [Delete Room API](https://matrix-org.github.io/synapse/latest/admin_api/rooms.html#delete-room-api) to block a room without the need to join it. ([\#11228](matrix-org/synapse#11228)) - Add an admin API to un-shadow-ban a user. ([\#11347](matrix-org/synapse#11347)) - Add an admin API to run background database schema updates. ([\#11352](matrix-org/synapse#11352)) - Add an admin API for blocking a room. ([\#11324](matrix-org/synapse#11324)) - Update the JWT login type to support custom a `sub` claim. ([\#11361](matrix-org/synapse#11361)) - Store and allow querying of arbitrary event relations. ([\#11391](matrix-org/synapse#11391)) Deprecations and Removals ------------------------- - Remove deprecated `trust_identity_server_for_password_resets` configuration flag. ([\#11333](matrix-org/synapse#11333), [\#11395](matrix-org/synapse#11395))
Synapse 1.48.0 (2021-11-30) =========================== This release removes support for the long-deprecated `trust_identity_server_for_password_resets` configuration flag. This release also fixes some performance issues with some background database updates introduced in Synapse 1.47.0. No significant changes since 1.48.0rc1. Synapse 1.48.0rc1 (2021-11-25) ============================== Features -------- - Experimental support for the thread relation defined in [MSC3440](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#3440). ([\matrix-org#11161](matrix-org#11161)) - Support filtering by relation senders & types per [MSC3440](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#3440). ([\matrix-org#11236](matrix-org#11236)) - Add support for the `/_matrix/client/v3` and `/_matrix/media/v3` APIs from Matrix v1.1. ([\matrix-org#11318](matrix-org#11318), [\matrix-org#11371](matrix-org#11371)) - Support the stable version of [MSC2778](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#2778): the `m.login.application_service` login type. Contributed by @tulir. ([\matrix-org#11335](matrix-org#11335)) - Add a new version of delete room admin API `DELETE /_synapse/admin/v2/rooms/<room_id>` to run it in the background. Contributed by @dklimpel. ([\matrix-org#11223](matrix-org#11223)) - Allow the admin [Delete Room API](https://matrix-org.github.io/synapse/latest/admin_api/rooms.html#delete-room-api) to block a room without the need to join it. ([\matrix-org#11228](matrix-org#11228)) - Add an admin API to un-shadow-ban a user. ([\matrix-org#11347](matrix-org#11347)) - Add an admin API to run background database schema updates. ([\matrix-org#11352](matrix-org#11352)) - Add an admin API for blocking a room. ([\matrix-org#11324](matrix-org#11324)) - Update the JWT login type to support custom a `sub` claim. ([\matrix-org#11361](matrix-org#11361)) - Store and allow querying of arbitrary event relations. ([\matrix-org#11391](matrix-org#11391)) Bugfixes -------- - Fix a long-standing bug wherein display names or avatar URLs containing null bytes cause an internal server error when stored in the DB. ([\matrix-org#11230](matrix-org#11230)) - Prevent [MSC2716](matrix-org/matrix-spec-proposals#2716) historical state events from being pushed to an application service via `/transactions`. ([\matrix-org#11265](matrix-org#11265)) - Fix a long-standing bug where uploading extremely thin images (e.g. 1000x1) would fail. Contributed by @Neeeflix. ([\matrix-org#11288](matrix-org#11288)) - Fix a bug, introduced in Synapse 1.46.0, which caused the `check_3pid_auth` and `on_logged_out` callbacks in legacy password authentication provider modules to not be registered. Modules using the generic module interface were not affected. ([\matrix-org#11340](matrix-org#11340)) - Fix a bug introduced in 1.41.0 where space hierarchy responses would be incorrectly reused if multiple users were to make the same request at the same time. ([\matrix-org#11355](matrix-org#11355)) - Fix a bug introduced in 1.45.0 where the `read_templates` method of the module API would error. ([\matrix-org#11377](matrix-org#11377)) - Fix an issue introduced in 1.47.0 which prevented servers re-joining rooms they had previously left, if their signing keys were replaced. ([\matrix-org#11379](matrix-org#11379)) - Fix a bug introduced in 1.13.0 where creating and publishing a room could cause errors if `room_list_publication_rules` is configured. ([\matrix-org#11392](matrix-org#11392)) - Improve performance of various background database updates. ([\matrix-org#11421](matrix-org#11421), [\matrix-org#11422](matrix-org#11422)) Improved Documentation ---------------------- - Suggest users of the Debian packages add configuration to `/etc/matrix-synapse/conf.d/` to prevent, upon upgrade, being asked to choose between their configuration and the maintainer's. ([\matrix-org#11281](matrix-org#11281)) - Fix typos in the documentation for the `username_available` admin API. Contributed by Stanislav Motylkov. ([\matrix-org#11286](matrix-org#11286)) - Add Single Sign-On, SAML and CAS pages to the documentation. ([\matrix-org#11298](matrix-org#11298)) - Change the word 'Home server' as one word 'homeserver' in documentation. ([\matrix-org#11320](matrix-org#11320)) - Fix missing quotes for wildcard domains in `federation_certificate_verification_whitelist`. ([\matrix-org#11381](matrix-org#11381)) Deprecations and Removals ------------------------- - Remove deprecated `trust_identity_server_for_password_resets` configuration flag. ([\matrix-org#11333](matrix-org#11333), [\matrix-org#11395](matrix-org#11395)) Internal Changes ---------------- - Add type annotations to `synapse.metrics`. ([\matrix-org#10847](matrix-org#10847)) - Split out federated PDU retrieval function into a non-cached version. ([\matrix-org#11242](matrix-org#11242)) - Clean up code relating to to-device messages and sending ephemeral events to application services. ([\matrix-org#11247](matrix-org#11247)) - Fix a small typo in the error response when a relation type other than 'm.annotation' is passed to `GET /rooms/{room_id}/aggregations/{event_id}`. ([\matrix-org#11278](matrix-org#11278)) - Drop unused database tables `room_stats_historical` and `user_stats_historical`. ([\matrix-org#11280](matrix-org#11280)) - Require all files in synapse/ and tests/ to pass mypy unless specifically excluded. ([\matrix-org#11282](matrix-org#11282), [\matrix-org#11285](matrix-org#11285), [\matrix-org#11359](matrix-org#11359)) - Add missing type hints to `synapse.app`. ([\matrix-org#11287](matrix-org#11287)) - Remove unused parameters on `FederationEventHandler._check_event_auth`. ([\matrix-org#11292](matrix-org#11292)) - Add type hints to `synapse._scripts`. ([\matrix-org#11297](matrix-org#11297)) - Fix an issue which prevented the `remove_deleted_devices_from_device_inbox` background database schema update from running when updating from a recent Synapse version. ([\matrix-org#11303](matrix-org#11303)) - Add type hints to storage classes. ([\matrix-org#11307](matrix-org#11307), [\matrix-org#11310](matrix-org#11310), [\matrix-org#11311](matrix-org#11311), [\matrix-org#11312](matrix-org#11312), [\matrix-org#11313](matrix-org#11313), [\matrix-org#11314](matrix-org#11314), [\matrix-org#11316](matrix-org#11316), [\matrix-org#11322](matrix-org#11322), [\matrix-org#11332](matrix-org#11332), [\matrix-org#11339](matrix-org#11339), [\matrix-org#11342](matrix-org#11342)) - Add type hints to `synapse.util`. ([\matrix-org#11321](matrix-org#11321), [\matrix-org#11328](matrix-org#11328)) - Improve type annotations in Synapse's test suite. ([\matrix-org#11323](matrix-org#11323), [\matrix-org#11330](matrix-org#11330)) - Test that room alias deletion works as intended. ([\matrix-org#11327](matrix-org#11327)) - Add type annotations for some methods and properties in the module API. ([\matrix-org#11341](matrix-org#11341)) - Fix running `scripts-dev/complement.sh`, which was broken in v1.47.0rc1. ([\matrix-org#11368](matrix-org#11368)) - Rename internal functions for token generation to better reflect what they do. ([\matrix-org#11369](matrix-org#11369), [\matrix-org#11370](matrix-org#11370)) - Add type hints to configuration classes. ([\matrix-org#11377](matrix-org#11377)) - Publish a `develop` image to Docker Hub. ([\matrix-org#11380](matrix-org#11380)) - Keep fallback key marked as used if it's re-uploaded. ([\matrix-org#11382](matrix-org#11382)) - Use `auto_attribs` on the `attrs` class `RefreshTokenLookupResult`. ([\matrix-org#11386](matrix-org#11386)) - Rename unstable `access_token_lifetime` configuration option to `refreshable_access_token_lifetime` to make it clear it only concerns refreshable access tokens. ([\matrix-org#11388](matrix-org#11388)) - Do not run the broken MSC2716 tests when running `scripts-dev/complement.sh`. ([\matrix-org#11389](matrix-org#11389)) - Remove dead code from supporting ACME. ([\matrix-org#11393](matrix-org#11393)) - Refactor including the bundled relations when serializing an event. ([\matrix-org#11408](matrix-org#11408))
Wasn't thrilled with how this one turned out. The implementation and API shape feels icky.
The first three commits are doc fixups. The rest should be okay to review commit-by-commit.