alpine php-fpm images

[eniac111]

@pierreozoux please, check it :)

Cheers!

[tilosp]

We should use the same php version as used by the other images, this would mean for nextcloud 9/10 php 5.6 and for nextcloud 11 php 7.1.

[tilosp]

Also you should use update.sh to generate the Dockerfiles and update .travis.yml

[eniac111]

Sure. I've been working on this yesterday.

[pierreozoux]

Agreed with @tilosp comments.

Thanks for your work, we are almost there!

[pierreozoux]

Isn't it possible to use pecl?
https://github.com/nextcloud/docker/blob/master/Dockerfile-php7.template#L38

[eniac111]

There were problems with php7 and Redis when I made the first version of the image but I'll try again. It would be cleaner.
Also, Memcache for php7 was broken then.

[JOduMonT]

in PHP7; is'nt it php-memcached instead of memcache ?
here it use alpine + php7 and memcached
https://github.com/linuxserver/docker-nextcloud/blob/master/Dockerfile

[pierreozoux]

Does it save a lot of time? I'd like to have images consistent and have the same logic.

[eniac111]

No, of course. It's not important. I'll remove it.

[pierreozoux]

Would it be possible to have the same layers accross images? This would allow us to DRY things in the future.

[eniac111]

Yes. I'll try to use the same layers for php 5.6.

[tilosp]

Closed and reopened to manually trigger a Travis build

[pierreozoux]

Just adding this email we received:

Hello everyone,

I wasn't sure where to direct this PR, since I don't have a GitHub account (I'd prefer not to create one). If you'd like me to direct it somewhere else, please let me know.

I had a need for some Alpine based Docker images of NextCloud, so I put some together using the official repo. Although, it looks like eniac111 beat me to it. Still, I think my builds are a little bit cleaner (and about 50% smaller). For comparison, I've put them in a table below with relative sizes. Mainly, these are more in-parallel with the templates already provided, and do a bit more cleanup. But as you can see, I think the pay-off speaks for itself in MBs; the final images come in smaller than the php:xx-fpm base images!

I hope that's helpful. If you would like me to amend anything, let me know an I can send a new PR.

Regards,

Deixismou
(Corey M. Bresnan)

E: [email protected]
E:  [email protected]


---- PHP Images

IMAGE  TAG                SIZE

php    7.1-fpm-alpine     69.6 MB
php    7.1-fpm            377 MB
php    7.1-apache         386 MB

php    5.6-fpm-alpine     54.5 MB
php    5.6-fpm            362 MB
php    5.6-apache         371 MB

---- Nextcloud Images

IMAGE                   TAG                 SIZE        COMPARE (% of fpm)

nextcloud (deixismou)   11.0-fpm-alpine     249 MB      40.75%
nextcloud (eniac111)    11.0-fpm-alpine     456 MB      74.63%
nextcloud               11.0-fpm            611 MB      100%
nextcloud               11.0-apache         620 MB      101.47%

nextcloud (deixismou)   10.0-fpm-alpine     217 MB      37.48%
nextcloud (eniac111)    10.0-fpm-alpine     440 MB      75.99%
nextcloud               10.0-fpm            579 MB      100%
nextcloud               10.0-apache         588 MB      101.55%

nextcloud (deixismou)   9.0-fpm-alpine      210 MB      36.71%
nextcloud (eniac111)    9.0-fpm-alpine      433 MB      75.70%
nextcloud               9.0-fpm             572 MB      100%
nextcloud               9.0-apache          581 MB      101.57%


The following changes since commit 2fcbef5c185891c5996a818c9d6d124481487a52:

  Fix failing docker build (2017-03-14 16:54:50 +0000)

are available in the git repository at:

  https://[email protected]/deixismou/docker-nextcloud.git master

[pierreozoux]

To keep in mind before merging: #65 (comment)

[tilosp]

Closing this for now