You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
create at least two groups group 1 and group 2 and three users (additionally to the admin)
assign each group a non-admin user as group admin (group admin 1, group admin 2)
add group admin 1 as member to group 2 (just normal member for group 2)
add another normal user to both groups
login as group admin 2 user
go to user configuration and click "delete" on the group admin 1
continue and delete the normal user as well
check the user settings as admin and notice that group admin 1 and the user are gone
Expected behaviour
The "deleted" users should be removed from the group only. The group admin should only be able to influence what happens in his group, but not further beyond.
That one group admin can delete another group admin, just because the other group admin is the same group should definitely not happen.
I know it is redundant if "delete" does the same like deselecting the check box of the group, but the current bahavior is just too fault-prone.
I would love to see some mechanism that checks if a user still belongs to another group or is a group admin. If so the user will only be removed from the current group.
Only if the current group is the only group the user belongs to, than the user can be deleted completely.
Actual behaviour
Both users (normal user and group admin user) are deleted completely.
Why this is a problem for me
I have many groups configured on my server and each group has a group admin. Some group admins are members of other groups and furthermore there are users, who are members of many groups.
Group admins are necessary so that they can add new users to the server (and to their group). They should also be allowed to remove users from their group again and delete them (if these users don't belong to another group any longer).
The big problem now is, that many of my users with group admin rights are not very experienced with IT stuff and a "delete" is pretty much the same as "remove" for them. Another group admin was already deleted by mistake and we need to avoid that.
Server version
I'm using the latest stable release, 12.0.3.3
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
Steps to reproduce
Expected behaviour
The "deleted" users should be removed from the group only. The group admin should only be able to influence what happens in his group, but not further beyond.
That one group admin can delete another group admin, just because the other group admin is the same group should definitely not happen.
I know it is redundant if "delete" does the same like deselecting the check box of the group, but the current bahavior is just too fault-prone.
I would love to see some mechanism that checks if a user still belongs to another group or is a group admin. If so the user will only be removed from the current group.
Only if the current group is the only group the user belongs to, than the user can be deleted completely.
Actual behaviour
Both users (normal user and group admin user) are deleted completely.
Why this is a problem for me
I have many groups configured on my server and each group has a group admin. Some group admins are members of other groups and furthermore there are users, who are members of many groups.
Group admins are necessary so that they can add new users to the server (and to their group). They should also be allowed to remove users from their group again and delete them (if these users don't belong to another group any longer).
The big problem now is, that many of my users with group admin rights are not very experienced with IT stuff and a "delete" is pretty much the same as "remove" for them. Another group admin was already deleted by mistake and we need to avoid that.
Server version
I'm using the latest stable release, 12.0.3.3
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: