Rococo beefy error: BadJustification("Duplicate consensus engine ID") on appending justification

[PierreBesson]

We are seeing those beefy error logs on all Rococo validators :

2023-09-27 12:03:17.432 ERROR tokio-runtime-worker beefy: 🥩 Error BadJustification("Duplicate consensus engine ID") on appending justification: V1(SignedCommitment { commitment: Commitment { payload: Payload([([109, 104], [187, 14, 3, 19, 80, 125, 51, 46, 42, 59, 190, 61, 0, 135, 58, 22, 51, 132, 226, 39, 58, 6, 197, 81, 216, 23, 21, 84, 136, 95, 12, 35])]), block_number: 7245951, validator_set_id: 12421 }, signatures: [None, Some(Signature(1f004404da0de1c7873fab3b6fa89ea467b081083e6cd162c7ddbd1dace93858798c567e4caef4a904dc740fbd01ef0075b469a42e02a4f70a307436be88f7cd01)), None, None, Some(Signature(18ee2ac46b6c7d9594bc62e0dc15a76a5383bf0c61ebdf4c8a8613763dff04b5017e81cebd0cd9419c45dd34d14e0b4b1edd79eaff0ba9c3a7ba5ff61b26dc0e01)), Some(Signature(3965712e637710099080d8852236ffd09adf0893c8472b67ad5eaf59ff4698cc09ab5da16381de4e63b18edd69870e3a1a4263e3cd4a323c44b9f574c7c5d7a501)), Some(Signature(7ab6ab048249a0bc7dbb56b56508d33f50d2db5f03d735f56d33716ec385c4b12645a021108f40531dd1f50c6ca14b307ed2f948e854d0eccd0cd43e1c62d45600)), Some(Signature(f0c2d5889ded3ac58d7c209cf877670cba4b5264fd210c9e40f44eb8b566e09e145c52a254c86750e029ca4b73803abc8ae72904da9a978993a1cf227448cd1e01)), None, Some(Signature(17dcb43cc9ad747d66ef1a9d35d797f90df9fb2f1f54fe99e5a757e9c2b2af637ec4005d0b5529cdb9500a47690a97e2379c4e49861d941897436165f512fb7600)), None, Some(Signature(0efca76ba0f425fea219afdf084c8bbd88c8b649aa1a223596788b1691fbf1165975fac9a2cc954e76e3247234acf93a876673eb9e92958a869ff7722a0faee300)), Some(Signature(f2e8c04cef4ad84c17abb5db6b0a10daa34d2548402957966d781b603ed2ec9203b9fb86a1757b4f1f7161361306ca1ac709039d2125689f6f580f3cf992eec201)), None, None, Some(Signature(003f1768d7f40127653929a4849791b4c623642204c223dfe12cc4b301a389cb04d051ddaba89b037e89cc97294b2c2072bc519738666d24ad88041c8b5dad4a00)), Some(Signature(b12a65e36056f67b78279569d53d89dee06a1c47f0bcfb8c9f0fd4326d6d41310a530ac6af6b31cfd6d3d774480efd2da1a104ca42d5b81c8ac3cd3814504c7500)), None, None, Some(Signature(d19efd220f15dd5e90247386e652e4ae3f6e5268179ac5b9e0522e88601b16db76ef0a84d45a426ba01e0fb0acac1629bffae034d64f672018a18980e4162aee00)), Some(Signature(82dc1970440b4628ede280a0226b6c76826bbc31e594fdff61feecc1f186a3a957b646e14c8c1f49a1de4e386fada1dd954a1a09bcc4b22dfcfe6a1826fc373300)), Some(Signature(9045a432c858e3e3bb549bf6212c363be778aadaa7058266d5a4b89108f35afe0762f3766a79bc8bebb53ddbce51fd2d93ada7532d85b6d1366c663da54a8f6d01)), None, Some(Signature(35a3ef53ef02cdd767b6e8bc1ea459794c0a0d61068872ce4a1ef3bc98153b9e2266d2d24b79d629bd4c622b779024e35928be2c3a5b13a12505bf64ddb756ba01)), Some(Signature(1357e92317d60428966c791de2ac6ab1ccd486a4b36d0b5dbe74bcd9be199d0c290eec32833fefb6ba527cb0b7ff70830497115029420cf10c32d32eda4f771401)), Some(Signature(3b5ee5e1a4bc3b105842867529d379424279bea931548a8ca2e0bef57bf10d5c15f4274b842ea4dcd19df35a7019761298ff981ff56ddbf1fcb43a9c8598d29100)), Some(Signature(5dac63eccb9e40eab4e828f51085a5dca7407e37c76592582b6925c06aa9e1977092039f300d131d57024ac2c48dfd2536d164036431b7f6264c8ff9495a50ae00)), None, Some(Signature(7eb1277eea8e1d117b9e7a38738d7a2948b2cef0c25e78d0339f4792b6667525740022569b26153e0a7bb1bb0b37851834982aea3b2cf291cfab286740cea21001)), Some(Signature(0f88ae2bda3fe0adf737739dfe4dc1a5de511d442a02bc2047fbfc760f6f8d74536c84202db264db1c2c12d0c2437f2c7bbc2ba3db46b9ee9835e972b5f9365d01)), None, None, None, Some(Signature(c9fe80187f0a2a729deebab038506625881f2908ed7196fa5012c9ab2c57fd026855615a2f6a607e9ea1a38be249ad7f5183160a3f5e8a215362f0193753891500)), Some(Signature(bd0836192a2e668fdf3d8831d9e2497883c2ed94b9863b4cff70ab323acd64c20e24234342d7635b6f8066ba4bbe274a1ddcafb2cd0bf3fb67acd9f0cef880b701)), None, None, Some(Signature(53e3a824cdfdfd0b7986a94fb7a8e65933dcf3737e7b41bc963fdb3079fefc326213717a54f0aa240eb955bb209873dacbfc41482d2982855da2f57b83e5343400)), Some(Signature(8d4a8696fce1def8b26a8185bc0ae78b1779433eb7e9d4cb1077a9db9fa25e3c40aaecbfbdb65608589c3ddd8e4c7808fee02e3056f0d2ee9f54a8774c3c7e6d01)), Some(Signature(d6263b2408ad76652f91a0dc765fb22b7d7a3219f5007ce40ddc8af11bc4d94417c13ce8f567e18a1b0692ed4ad134456dad0e1db82848a64987fc7380325b6100)), Some(Signature(d42d08aeb75ff1813511d37f0634d47d0eeab2dff9d754052dc54d912cf24885403b868593676af7590a84145ba136bde0b23d49538008ee659abed193b985d300)), Some(Signature(25ca12d7fcb5aeea6dba8898c3231feaf9b8611eaa617b098c5e32e44d6ad9b97c268f52f5ced6286457c64b36e0e581191ff9759967037dbd8299677861cd0d01)), None, Some(Signature(6ba37b571d0f3e0bbf838d66417192884b86a8cb9933804aa55a0738ff9e26b81b748529cd952624727ff4a07b255569ee91468d29546f792c01c139026bdeec00)), Some(Signature(d34b50a938444067fe19f94b6f6b490515b3aa98c9d4bde455d46c65980f12d374a844dfa874a8ec7c9d7af8169673a131630645481cae0abe5b2af52313b39200)), None, Some(Signature(f92f2a85da359b30a21764ea55ae458f83ffe8c0daf2e9fd91c3a4ea6348286d5f246a18b273947f7811bcde2d6dbb0e040ce5328688cf26231b94d5d6dbd3a900)), Some(Signature(2fb993aa6889cc88b878e15250810484f735c4f0ca194214c3c9da798d71807755e0e7e83a743719ed0f4ede7f8875b1d160b49bdeedc5df32abac98a779da3a01)), None, Some(Signature(add2dda3d08624b3d638966987da07dbbec9fd95185db3a73cdb5049df45cabf316cf314dd46ee440e6f4a1089f1aa7d527aa3a0b2c2771de58358cb96daa84b00)), Some(Signature(e802d47c9eaaa69d1a9fd66f18541293a3880e8a5fcfff5a0f70aafcdc4b450e3f17f6c9ec036e00e0be0296c9c97f4995629194d989a4e50005ee0937fdb46601)), None, Some(Signature(58d9df342c01bbe13ad05b08c2ab5bd4ec48d7b60b8ba4f27e951bf218cfed9618b349e6503f94c1b4cc8e1602bfc8b07313c64f7b0e0976845434457a5b749e00)), Some(Signature(6df5f4098213f4ddc95f674b78dd23dd730435f28202aa0dd3adfd1ffa3e9e7e4172ce07789ad6409ac130e5022e5607c525f0d0fe257cb74d82f193e973756300)), None, Some(Signature(57af4f0cf8bcc499e20d31372f13fa31e33cf87e9e90616d9300714a8056f44770b8f26113f56370fa57eeb6ef48c34a4a4faef66d27e97d74432ed683638bb201)), Some(Signature(d3be560ccf75525c20ba7b98b4499a47ccd2a861835aec32b0c09650c06aae42454560c3391f66dcaaddcd7f6d92b9a32ffe4482dc4de5c9b84ce5b0dcad75a001)), Some(Signature(d2aa168bee683d49ee3d8d0cba0cb8956afbc1ff1a9760acc74bb392f85402977bed40ded477fdcc5c844c9cf781612fcc6ee29bcca867fc55409397b79a049301)), Some(Signature(47dd24a1df6c5950783af27ac6214dee7af0bda7cd18c494b40b16b1aae6e8701bf3cfa2478fcb77b29e0bcc423bcf46142f9727c7194c6fb84ba2fd1e93e8f401)), Some(Signature(f700ae84b26bc2612e095de94871d7506cca7d445a1090b1ff65c4d395a8c0c949eb93325e86bbad449da51595498f7302c30e7373c0c7752c5721f1958f0dbd00)), None, Some(Signature(931da2bada4bacceb435e8fc79c348ab56765c87e5d13aabd4ad977c1562b0105ef63c7efa0abf7a0fdfd641c20d3e981b815753cc276cd98d9b9c518dcaf29b01)), Some(Signature(bf066b7dd57ff8ba9aa628cabaac037dac827ffb7f6a77e01c714139812c195b39fd154bd599ecda5861b1244d6d39ee7a2a05f6e8a5182e6fbd80b78a86bcff01)), Some(Signature(3b5edcd0fc2ca58db8b8bfecc4668a308d56f1680e5519fbb7f4c0873d3511ba1ec0a7b606197d35d0878baa7b0dd046d47e36b2182da8672583d746cea381b800)), None, Some(Signature(bcc4b2fbf611aadc22a049bc0466d86ad87d9207f1a50ba6f4bb6ece15461272713ae500d7e3c14e20e2f0107b25ca7e413b6ca4bae4f0d6537e87d251f052d801)), Some(Signature(2c78445681236c3fce482e8c56a621ef1f4049c3ef205506af2ec5e7f7ebe6b342b14ae3783847a1fba123076797046eba212156379fd6bdb2a49d0aca273f7301)), Some(Signature(5b343580af4e1efceb30d705492a64ce6f3e00dd35247d5a748242f84d1017a36aa73a374b731efe7e813f7309645370710019aab690241e912dc3cd06e80bc900)), Some(Signature(c1f8948a761232dabe5f021af2dd4a17e431a2fa5b7e24f4a7e3c0edb905127359ba0f9dcde283f32c79f22d33c2f3f0e13f1caf728e182b7181f74a007bc5eb01)), Some(Signature(6f860aa5db39a7022bb6af5cefcd3fd4c73043ffa156fef2087f701891901e6f1ebca070464ca12cb029a292c7424dbb5c11de7dbe60886d61834abd2cddc85f01)), Some(Signature(21231461c359ddf76d4681c82c0146e79b31039e138c742c806a252513e14ba572a8a4e3ba2fcbbbcf0d7024eebd532fcc3ea003771cad4899625cfd7af65cf700)), Some(Signature(06955ceda2a6bc851862547c8aa9a6325b83adb30b66819be843561bdc1c0d104ba7e6b78a6cea89afad811ed86f748159fd52d3078f94e156232cc3d8057a9101)), Some(Signature(bf7ca96a26da4b245a8d478b06fd23719a313b4b299a60133c5a281b1e24fb6d2719e14bc06ab41856acf1173f6be734545dc8ad91e3fa8827e47f4e597efc3901)), Some(Signature(72f9e070f88d205126ae991c3b2f9ab4e410314cf0eaf756731bf8f7e2868ba802449b8e2b06d1464d1d960e868d45924b68f9107911022501aff0dbd42d2a8a00)), Some(Signature(dde7c5ce40f39eab9ec8d59f63f57ab290498da28bbeb2c0cd5410b4f8d8365f535b72fca64675b9824004210c3fcc28d7f471d4177cb1a66017346ab38b30c401)), Some(Signature(086f59fbb58ccf5028447f33041ae1bacf8b3a49820d89b41a9dde19d95201c65f13d3c841daab0a0823cc53012a7c9cb86a2d14e6274bc1c2ce76e68f5101bb00)), Some(Signature(9ee53e9dcbbe5be5cbbe21f525b79e4d963a6c5e5fbbe1f33daa79a9c8786651089405507921bd4ba6b0175f0fca38228f70c907eac51aa4902f4f273b478a5f00)), Some(Signature(b7367591667222b10959086460338559d3ac1fb8376b312b40637d1fa2dbd917246118841be9ed8a86b95a0ad1df92c976f34bde8b79c8d59b80e151fd4538d100)), Some(Signature(b2c171b0866b0f5f731c26b18bf9497574529696d95e659b643ff910b3ab87260fd4be87f710dc2433ef10a4387bf7025b581fd4979e168110bc71e063be4a1501)), Some(Signature(7dd5ea21a09b65b61b82b81e180d99b7af77929ca9759962217aaa5bee35884f6466ce66acce083f81c382558d93b7ad5e9e641aa0c3c981b29ca2c22762cc0a00)), Some(Signature(66388222fc8ac46a0f2d9cd8f738cbf5d97b3268a386918e35f20d29b724099149a3561ab880f44659bc40c9f339b4cdba9f1580b3970ae92c5e4a033569c94901)), Some(Signature(856480c069df75d49c64f5e21d925a672e3be7c274ce12be649ab550ffe0d0a204558d4db4ed96f42ee91bc2a4e9eb55578452b9d82278941f3959abce2eef6101)), Some(Signature(51c9078d793c7e56198dc00880cfb71f3dd6cd96866de0a74be8aedba75a6fe0782fb58b8d193d86821c0304f2a3fc09463f06c16a0f54bb17751c849f4a297500)), Some(Signature(4869cec4e9167d5788d779414797784d15265aaf3ea5fa0d11084cced8548c6b19938ff9b5b41b94818ebcd8a29d9482783759391b83f6a000fa286a6b21f14101)), None, Some(Signature(a4eff3914bb4964f0d9a8072a7a29b8cd819fa1fbb897c9b67c915a23a2dd4d9101ce3bc38757f23dcc4c7c15af253e16e0fc40b71962e54291a8b60df4a3e6f01)), Some(Signature(48615fbd52dcb446d0dd959f4896d2a180166c83b3fe3e2d5c9e1cccbe7891a80802001e19032043eb45354da169c87c95c643927b0164ce7566049ebe99c06401)), Some(Signature(83843d6a4f5465a25d29dce26bb55adc7e84f6e64bd54727110b815ca24b414179d6ce5c0b3aedc57004fd3ca8cd0eb1e902de09feadb63a48bf9e9b2fbafe8900)), Some(Signature(a82838b05772b415f2532ca59646a9a23775019d068e4efa7de5ec21275a3a0a49e20ebb7631988045e45a8f31bb5397a043be0e8ff87224bd1604d683557b9c00)), Some(Signature(5bee26848a7a2ab0285da114bf75f5f69cdfb9d897a3dccdcd72f3f5fa0df9964327ab98ca1a263b96fa2bee6b4ae51bfcc359a515e7c5fced5cc498ed3d940f00)), Some(Signature(fda3098dfde921ba62c0372bb1a46f395e2809c1f28c28f2b9379602b3da2c97623b5d5346f5d799537f8910fd33ab55ae9bbaa3426f63cface7dc15d521283f00)), Some(Signature(cdf72acf769288ab550806f376a9c696333911b20e9478a9dce7bb006e174f8a4d16de9b44888a870cc5742dec5047d493543a5e0b6c04a34578b14e07276c4800)), Some(Signature(0113504c18085b1b168c673977c4e5a4a7d11e37013b83a860a91ea223a8815c7894e4b2d42684c872a392825760939da0028864b11645e9c2e50062862690aa00)), None, Some(Signature(66fb0f77904152217aee35b911fb0182b4feec545a1c9a8782ef933e227a4d6969d51f9823505fe121ffd24f4bc612b0270e74669f663b932dd378713ade7a3c00)), None, None, None, Some(Signature(c8065ce6a413b3500b5a77667a693794a737ae91bd06e814c512003904a88d3e2b3487f70bf723dbdcf4adab6d41b654f6bf34d7658c4c235718e8c3a043229700)), Some(Signature(f91a89437a5c3135c5f28eed55b24b9f9d92a8db01f665bf05383182014c53de73df6dc14cb5dad4f908314a212eabfea235034d1bc191cf6bfebbf5f142be4601)), Some(Signature(c0c0a4606370aa0198b78fe8708ad929ae1beb94328747e7f0e924862243e568165ba3a63ec8d23530e4eec7ce8083ec13eeaeb3ff2c2ee89e32b245f1ea0de100)), Some(Signature(9d412efb97647046c23b37832299e4007561af9ccfe7e1ced39340fca4552e6900487568154f59348dddcb21a2e9eb2f734ece3a116cc3b4019ceb5f5f4c1ce400)), None, None, None, None, None, None, None, None, Some(Signature(fd128342516de1ef24a1d1636f5ceeb96abbf63d3430b1f45f76b3941ab36aa6636ba275b826bc4eccc7d448ab1aaa9180d77c7921b8e1aa09bb082d9ea51a5001))] }) |  

@acatangiu

[acatangiu]

This is not an actual issue, but it is a distracting annoyance. Opened #1852 to fix it and also improve the protocol usage a bit.