Yield Err in char::decode_utf8 per Unicode, like String::from_utf8_lossy

src/libcore/char.rs

@@ -737,25 +737,81 @@ pub struct InvalidSequence(());
 impl<I: Iterator<Item = u8>> Iterator for DecodeUtf8<I> {
     type Item = Result<char, InvalidSequence>;
     #[inline]
+
     fn next(&mut self) -> Option<Result<char, InvalidSequence>> {
-        self.0.next().map(|b| {
-            if b & 0x80 == 0 { Ok(b as char) } else {
-                let l = (!b).leading_zeros() as usize; // number of bytes in UTF-8 representation
-                if l < 2 || l > 6 { return Err(InvalidSequence(())) };
-                let mut x = (b as u32) & (0x7F >> l);
-                for _ in 0..l-1 {
+        self.0.next().map(|first_byte| {
+            // Emit InvalidSequence according to
+            // Unicode §5.22 Best Practice for U+FFFD Substitution
+            // http://www.unicode.org/versions/Unicode9.0.0/ch05.pdf#G40630
+
+            // Roughly: consume at least one byte,
+            // then validate one byte at a time and stop before the first unexpected byte
+            // (which might be the valid start of the next byte sequence).
+
+            let mut code_point;
+            macro_rules! first_byte {
+                ($mask: expr) => {
+                    code_point = u32::from(first_byte & $mask)
+                }
+            }
+            macro_rules! continuation_byte {
+                () => { continuation_byte!(0x80...0xBF) };
+                ($range: pat) => {
                     match self.0.peek() {
-                        Some(&b) if b & 0xC0 == 0x80 => {
+                        Some(&byte @ $range) => {
+                            code_point = (code_point << 6) | u32::from(byte & 0b0011_1111);
                             self.0.next();
-                            x = (x << 6) | (b as u32) & 0x3F;
-                        },
-                        _ => return Err(InvalidSequence(())),
+                        }
+                        _ => return Err(InvalidSequence(()))
                     }
                 }
-                match from_u32(x) {
-                    Some(x) if l == x.len_utf8() => Ok(x),
-                    _ => Err(InvalidSequence(())),
+            }
+
+            match first_byte {
+                0x00...0x7F => {
+                    first_byte!(0b1111_1111);
+                }
+                0xC2...0xDF => {
+                    first_byte!(0b0001_1111);
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                }
+                0xE0 => {
+                    first_byte!(0b0000_1111);
+                    continuation_byte!(0xA0...0xBF);  // 0x80...0x9F here are overlong
+                    continuation_byte!();
                 }
+                0xE1...0xEC | 0xEE...0xEF => {
+                    first_byte!(0b0000_1111);
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                }
+                0xED => {
+                    first_byte!(0b0000_1111);
+                    continuation_byte!(0x80...0x9F);  // 0xA0..0xBF here are surrogates
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                }
+                0xF0 => {
+                    first_byte!(0b0000_0111);
+                    continuation_byte!(0x90...0xBF);  // 0x80..0x8F here are overlong
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                }
+                0xF1...0xF3 => {
+                    first_byte!(0b0000_0111);
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                }
+                0xF4 => {
+                    first_byte!(0b0000_0111);
+                    continuation_byte!(0x80...0x8F);  // 0x90..0xBF here are beyond char::MAX
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                    continuation_byte!();
+                }
+                _ => return Err(InvalidSequence(()))  // Illegal first byte, overlong, or beyond MAX
+            }
+            unsafe {
+                Ok(from_u32_unchecked(code_point))
             }
         })
     }

src/libcoretest/char.rs

@@ -358,29 +358,50 @@ fn eu_iterator_specializations() {
 
 #[test]
 fn test_decode_utf8() {
-    use core::char::*;
-    use core::iter::FromIterator;
-
-    for &(str, bs) in [("", &[] as &[u8]),
-                       ("A", &[0x41u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�", &[0xC1u8, 0x81u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("♥", &[0xE2u8, 0x99u8, 0xA5u8]),
-                       ("♥A", &[0xE2u8, 0x99u8, 0xA5u8, 0x41u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�", &[0xE2u8, 0x99u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�A", &[0xE2u8, 0x99u8, 0x41u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�", &[0xC0u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�A", &[0xC0u8, 0x41u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�", &[0x80u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�A", &[0x80u8, 0x41u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�", &[0xFEu8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�A", &[0xFEu8, 0x41u8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�", &[0xFFu8] as &[u8]),
-                       ("�A", &[0xFFu8, 0x41u8] as &[u8])].into_iter() {
-        assert!(Iterator::eq(str.chars(),
-                             decode_utf8(bs.into_iter().map(|&b|b))
-                                 .map(|r_b| r_b.unwrap_or('\u{FFFD}'))),
-                "chars = {}, bytes = {:?}, decoded = {:?}", str, bs,
-                Vec::from_iter(decode_utf8(bs.into_iter().map(|&b|b))
-                                   .map(|r_b| r_b.unwrap_or('\u{FFFD}'))));
+    macro_rules! assert_decode_utf8 {
+        ($input_bytes: expr, $expected_str: expr) => {
+            let input_bytes: &[u8] = &$input_bytes;
+            let s = char::decode_utf8(input_bytes.iter().cloned())
+                .map(|r_b| r_b.unwrap_or('\u{FFFD}'))
+                .collect::<String>();
+            assert_eq!(s, $expected_str,
+                       "input bytes: {:?}, expected str: {:?}, result: {:?}",
+                       input_bytes, $expected_str, s);
+            assert_eq!(String::from_utf8_lossy(&$input_bytes), $expected_str);
+        }
     }
+
+    assert_decode_utf8!([], "");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0x41], "A");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xC1, 0x81], "��");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xE2, 0x99, 0xA5], "♥");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xE2, 0x99, 0xA5, 0x41], "♥A");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xE2, 0x99], "�");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xE2, 0x99, 0x41], "�A");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xC0], "�");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xC0, 0x41], "�A");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0x80], "�");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0x80, 0x41], "�A");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xFE], "�");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xFE, 0x41], "�A");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xFF], "�");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xFF, 0x41], "�A");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xC0, 0x80], "��");
+
+    // Surrogates
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xED, 0x9F, 0xBF], "\u{D7FF}");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xED, 0xA0, 0x80], "���");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xED, 0xBF, 0x80], "���");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xEE, 0x80, 0x80], "\u{E000}");
+
+    // char::MAX
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xF4, 0x8F, 0xBF, 0xBF], "\u{10FFFF}");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xF4, 0x8F, 0xBF, 0x41], "�A");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xF4, 0x90, 0x80, 0x80], "����");
+
+    // 5 and 6 bytes sequence
+    // Part of the original design of UTF-8,
+    // but invalid now that UTF-8 is artificially restricted to match the range of UTF-16.
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xF8, 0x80, 0x80, 0x80, 0x80], "�����");
+    assert_decode_utf8!([0xFC, 0x80, 0x80, 0x80, 0x80, 0x80], "������");
 }